Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Civic Engagement Scholarship: What We Can Learn from the Research

Sat, October 2, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Record setting turnout in the 2020 Presidential election belies the fact that the state of civic discourse in the United States has reach an historic low. While record numbers may be engaged through the ballot box, political divisions and the vitriol characterizing political debate haven’t been this toxic since the 19th century. A lack of consensus around basic facts and the lack of rudimentary knowledge of our civic institutions have been among the core factors contributing to this discord. Accordingly, the need to promote civic knowledge, skills and dispositions have never been greater. It behooves educators in the field of US politics and public policy to turbo-charge civic engagement so as to cultivate constructive citizenship among students from secondary school to graduate levels.

Fortunately, scholars have been advancing this field steadily over the last decade. Dozens of articles in leading political science journals like PS: Political Science & Politics and the Journal of Political Science Education (JPSE) have shared research and insights into this burgeoning field. Several years ago, a literature review article, “Best Practices in Civic Education: Lessons from the Journal of Political Science Education” (Bennion & Laughlin), distilled some of these insights so as to provide a resource to scholars in civic education on what others have done, learned and suggestions on where to go next.

Now the time is ripe for an expanded literature review that will incorporate up to date articles from these leading journals. Such a comprehensive survey will help to derive lessons for expanding civic engagement pedagogies in ways crucial to helping us to address the critical issues facing our country today. This literature review will build upon some of the methodologies provided in the Bennion/Laughlin article, such as a matrix for organizing information around sub-fields, interventions and assessment methods to facilitate comparisons from previous research efforts and help instructors and researchers access learnings on civic engagement in one place.

The literature review will also be structured to highlight issues topical to the 2021 APSA conference. Pluralism is of critical concern given the deep divides in our country. One issue that has become clear in the realm of civic engagement is that there’s no one-size-fits-all approach. Deployment of varied methodologies are critical to reach students who come from broadly diverse backgrounds. Multiple community contexts have a bearing on the way students might engaged with their communities and an array of assessments methods are utilized to determine the efficacy of various interventions.

This literature review will also account for the urgency of our situation by facilitating replication of methodologies that may be employed in other contexts. Emphasis will also be place on models that allow for collaboration with other fields. By definition, “engagement” implies interaction with fields and disciplines outside the traditional boundaries of political science education. Civic learning can occur through service-learning in disciplines across the spectrum of the liberal arts as well as sciences, engineering, etc. This review of the literature will seek out and highlight examples of collaborations across a variety of fields. Moreover, increasingly research in civic engagement is happening globally which offers opportunities to learn from diverse cultural contexts with civic traditions different from our own. The way that civic engagement is pursued in authoritarian contexts, for example, may be revelatory in our rapidly changing global community.

Now more than ever, we need to distill the learning in this field in a way that is useful and accessible in a variety of contexts through a range of disciplines. Scholarship in the area of civic engagement has been challenged with the development of assessment tools to gauge the impact of various interventions on civic knowledge and engagement both in the short and long term. Comparing the range and development of assessment tools will be one aspect explored through in this review of literature on the topic.

Social and digital media is rapidly evolving and increasingly impacting our civic discourse. Students especially may find digital platforms as their major venue for engaging with their community. Reviewing literature that researches this dynamic area may provide useful insights for research going forward.

This literature review will focus on distilling learnings from recent scholarship on civic engagement in ways that will be actionable and useful to educators across disciplines and at different educational levels.

Authors