Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

How Wartime Experiences Affect Postwar Security Decisions

Thu, September 30, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

How do wartime experiences affect postwar security choices? Rationalist theories of war contend that fighting a war reveals information and leads to a war-ending convergence of beliefs about the relative strength of each side, but both the degree to which beliefs about relative strength persist after the war ends and how the information revealed on the battlefield affects later security choices such as potentially renewing the war are less clear. In this paper, I argue that more direct experiences during wars are more likely than indirect experiences to lead to individual-level shifts in long-term beliefs about the relative strength of each side. Information from more direct experiences is particularly more likely to overcome psychological resistance to admitting defeat on the part of a defeated side compared to indirect information from secondhand sources. Thus the extent to which decision-makers, including the public in democratic states, directly experience fighting during the war will affect the degree to which postwar security decisions are more or less militaristic.

To test this argument, I analyze the case of France during and after the Franco-Prussian War, a hard case for this argument since the embarrassing military performance of France during that war has typically been portrayed as leading to a populist thirst for “revenge” against Germany that led into World War I. First, I use electoral and demographic data to show how more direct wartime experiences in the form of casualties and German occupation reduced support for more militaristic political parties and anti-German patriotic organizations in France after the war. Second, I use qualitative evidence from writings, meeting minutes, and speeches to trace how the wartime experiences of several major French politicians affected their postwar policy towards Germany. Leaders who more directly experienced the war by being present in Paris during its siege were less supportive of militancy and more willing to diplomatically work with Germany after the war than leaders who remained far from the front. These findings suggest that how a war is fought and experienced plays a major role in shaping foreign policy and the chances of sustaining peace after the fighting ends.

Author