Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
The paper explores the role of remembering in democratic decision-making. While prevailing approaches in democratic theory – such as deliberative democracy – emphasize the importance of time-consuming procedures and discourses for democratic legitimacy, a systematic analysis of this time requirement and its implications is lacking. In contrast, sociological acceleration theory questions whether democracies still have sufficient time at all. According to the thesis of acceleration theorists, the economic, cultural and technical subsystems of modern society progress at such a fast pace that democratic decision-making notoriously comes too late. The result is a de-synchronization between democratic politics and the rest of society. Politicians are caught in the bind of either accelerating processes at the cost of diminished capacity for adequate deliberation or (authoritatively) decelerating the other social systems at the cost of decreased efficiency.
The paper assumes that the focus on the linear-progressive dimension of time, which is dominant in such approaches, ignores the importance of the past. Therefore, the paper asks what role collective remembering (and forgetting) plays in democratic decision-making. It argues that democratic conflicts always have a – varying – historical depth dimension. This dimension is to be described by the newly introduced concept of the "democratic archive", which systematically captures those practices, structures, and media in which experiences and stocks of knowledge are stored that can be referred to in decision-making situations. Following the theory of collective and cultural memory and other cultural-theoretical approaches, I sketch the mechanisms through which the democratic archive provides opportunities for mobilizing knowledge, arguments and identities acquired through earlier political conflicts. However, the "democratic archive" allows for the reconstruction of both the potential for adaptation and possible pathologies which arise from the historical depth dimension of democracies in concrete decision-making situations.
This argument is then illustrated using a comparative case study of two policy making processes in Germany, which vary in the historical dimension of their underlying conflict. The first case, the German nuclear phase-out of 2012, demonstrates an instance where the use of the democratic archive is strongly evident. The various materials – contending positions, simulations, technical scenarios, arguments, and so forth – accumulated over the decades-long conflict were used to secure both a very quick and legitimate decision-making process. In contrast, the Euro rescue package of 2011 is examined as a typical case for the de-synchronization theses because the quickness of the decision was bought at the cost of the legitimacy of the decision-making process. In the latter case, the democratic archive was almost empty because the conflict was relatively new.
The paper concludes by discussing the trade-offs that the use of democratic archives can bring about and indicates the methodological and theoretical implications for the assessment of the temporal dimension of democratic systems. In this way, the temporal problem of democracy is brought into a new light.