Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Informal Workers' Compliance and Social Capital During COVID-19 in Indonesia

Sat, October 2, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

In the struggle of lower income countries to contain the Covid-19 pandemic, informal workers in dense developing cities have become a linchpin. When community infections are rising, nonpharmaceutical interventions require convincing citizens to voluntarily comply for the benefit of the society. Globally, two billion people earn wages or own-account income in jobs that lack formal registration or employment-based social insurance, and are both vulnerable and consequential in this situation. Using original representative mobile survey of Indonesian workers in four major urban informal economic sectors across 32 provinces, I show that informal workers generally express lower support for strict public health policies, such as bans on economic and social activities, but social capital in the form of community and membership-based local associations correlates with increased policy acceptance. Using survey experiment, I further show that voluntary compliance by informal workers rises significantly when policy information is communicated via such associations, but direct digital messaging from the government is met with skepticism. The results are robust and apply across informal workers in traditional sectors as well as urban service jobs affected by emerging digital platforms, but I find stronger effects among informal workers who participate in associations in real life. Individual traits such as education or information access do not explain this evidence. I use qualitative evidence and text analysis to illustrate that both selection and structural pathways cause informal workers’ social associations to facilitate greater compliance with controversial government policies. I discuss my findings’ implications for the theories of the politics of economic informality beyond the pandemic, including direct and indirect policies of labor formalization.

Author