Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Cross-Boundary Collaboration and Public Value Creation

Tue, September 28, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Over the past decade, collaboration governance and management have gained much popularity as a strategy to develop solutions to complex and "wicket problems". Collaborative governance processes and management strategies bring together multiple stakeholders in a context of decision making, implementation and shared risk to mitigate organizational challenges and wicket problems which in order wise cannot be solved by unilateral action (Agranoff & Mcguire, 2003a, p. 4; Ulibarri, 2015; Ansell & Gash, 2008; Fishkin, 2011; Innes & Booher, 2018; Fisher, Ury, & Patton, 2011; Emerson, Nabatchi, & Balogh, 2012). A well-executed collaborative governance leads to improve and effective solutions, management of task and functions, implementation and less risk burden because of the diverse participating stakeholders who share both actions and responsibilities (Emerson & Nabatchi 2015; Ulibarri, 2015). Cross-boundary collaboration is therefore expected to result in improved public value creation than that from its alternatives or a single acting organization. However, because cross-boundary collaboration involves multiple actors with diverse policy-making process, it is criticized for being less accountable (Rhodes & Wanna, 2007; Moore, 1995); feared that private and non-profit organizations involved in collaboration may garner illicit benefits through the close relationship they build with other sectors (page et al., 2015; Papadopoulos 2007; Toring, 2012; Lowndes 2001); and criticized as an avenue for conflict and confusion because of multiple mandates and reporting requirements from multiple sectors (Waterman & Meier 1998; Willems & van Dooren 2011; Sørensen 2012). With these concerns, processes and strategies adopted in cross-boundary collaborations must therefore strive to create public value.
Concomitantly, assessing the efficacy of collaborative governance processes and activities in promoting public value like accountability and substantive outcome is challenging and limited in the literature (Page, Stone, Bryson, and Crosby, 2015; Agranoff, 2008; 2007; Koebele, 2015). Public value from cross-boundary collaboration is theorized to emerge from both vertical complexities and horizontal complexities which makes their assessment difficult and mostly overlooked (Choi, Cho, et. al., 2005; Agranoff, 2008; page et al., 2015; Emerson & Nabatchi 2015). Hence, the performance of collaborative governance process and activities in achieving its intended policy goals remain under-explored (Berry & Brower, 2005; Choi, Cho, Wright & Brudney, 2005; Agranoff, 2008; Emerson & Nabatchi 2015; Emerson et al., 2012). Consequently, scholars have long call for the evaluation of cross-boundary collaboration in enhancing accountability and substantive outcomes in the literature (Bryson et al., 2015; Emerson & Nabatchi 2015; Emerson, et. al., 2012; Innes & Booher 1999; Koontz & Thomas 2006; O’Leary & Bingham 2003; Newig & Fritsch 2009; Thomas & Koontz 2011; Thomson, Perry, & Miller 2008, 2009) which therefore begs our attention.
Notwithstanding this, the issue of accountability has been raised particularly in developing countries' context where structures for accountability are mostly inadequate and challenging. This issue is exacerbating when a non-profit organization initiate and lead a collaborative governance arrangement who normally see less need to be accountable to other stakeholders other than their funders. Few studies have therefore been conducted to assess the effect of intergovernmental and intersectoral collaboration in creating public value especially in developing countries' context where non-profit organizations mostly lead intersectoral collaborations. While previous literature focus on how collaborative governance and management arrangement extend the process of decision-making and implementation outward to private and non-governmental organizations, we explore a collaborative governance and management arrangement where the process of decision-making and implementation along with activities are extended outward from a non-profit organization as a lead initiator to governmental organizations. In this case, a principle - agent relationship exist where the non-profit organization influence and shape the expected performance of the state and local governments (Berry & Brower, 2005). Specifically, we focus on how the existence of such collaborative governance and management arrangement result in public value creation like accountability, procedural legitimacy and substantive outcomes. Also, this exploration expands our knowledge on the effect of collaborative arrangement on the role of government and how such arrangement serve its intended purpose of creating public value. To achieve the research goals, we formulate two research questions. First, does vertical collaborative activities/processes result in public value creation? Second, does horizonal collaborative activities/processes result in public value creation?

Authors