Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
ABSTRACT
The paper analyses role of Panchayat a traditional dispute resolution system amongst tribal communities through social innovation approach. Using governance perspective, the paper also seeks to explore whether one or both of these justice systems benefit the rural population and is there any requirement for improvement to expand accessibility to justice. The legal archival and literature review identified similarities and differences, strengths and weaknesses of both the justice systems for induced policy suggestions. Although, the state’s official justice system requires reforms to improve accessibility of justice but, for the majority rural population, Panchayat system is a convenient and affordable means of accessing justice compared to the official system which is limited in urban centers, expensive, and cumbersome. From the perspective of classical liberalism both rural and modern viewpoints could be established involving views of rural communities into the peculiarities of both the systems to assess public preferences and consequential side-effects.
Introduction
Pakistan government mandating through its policies (via Ministry of Law & Justice, Supreme Court of Pakistan, National Assembly and Senate of Pakistan) that government, judiciary and Bar Councils adopt public friendly policies highlighting the importance of access to justice in the official legal system through the introduction of various recent legislations such as; Legal Practitioners and Bar Councils (Amendment) Act, 2018 (“to provide free specialized services for awareness, promotion and enforcement of human rights”), Alternative Dispute Resolution Act, 2017 (“a process in which parties resort to resolving a dispute other than by adjudication by Courts and includes, but is not limited to, arbitration, mediation, conciliation and neutral evaluation”), Alternative Dispute Resolution Rules, 2018 (compliments the ADR, 2017 to provide administrative services and usage of internet technology for communication purpose etc.), Costs of Litigation Act, 2017 (applies only to Islamabad capital territory courts wherein litigants may get reimbursed by providing the statement amount spent throughout the case including lawyer’s fees but excluding court procedural costs), Right of Access to Information Act, 2017 (“an Act to provide for the right of access to information in transparent and effective manner, subject only to reasonable restrictions imposed by law”, this Act also advises government bodies to maintain updated and proper record keeping), The Punjab Village Panchayats and Neighborhood Councils (Amendment) Ordinance, 2019 (applicable in Punjab province only, it seeks cooperation of village councils during election, land issues and population census).
Literature regarding Panchayat system is very limited and the available one is mainly published in the Indian context. This research contributes to the limited literature on Panchayat in Pakistani context. Government reports such as from Supreme Court of Pakistan (SCB, 2020) and Federal Judicial Academy (Hussain, 2015) served as government source of information on understanding the structure of Pakistani courts. Recent research by Farooqi, et. al. (2019), Shah, et. al. (2018), Qaisrani (2018) and Riaz, et. al (2017) were fruitful in understanding the issues of justice accessibility in Pakistani courts and cost of justice. But none of the studies focus on structural issues of accessing justice and comparing accessibility to justice in two different systems is a recent addition to this debate. The overarching research question for this study is to explore the role of traditional justice system in providing justice to tribal communities, maintaining social order, stability and harmony and how social innovation approach could facilitate improve justice and improve upon criticisms.
The weaknesses of the official legal systems are in fact plus points of the Panchayat. Panchayats are not run like a typical hierarchical system of official courts. The proceedings are both deductive and inductive, and unlike the official court, a complainant can communicate directly to the council. Unlike the official system, appointment into the decision-making council of Panchayat is done through a democratic process where community puts their trust into selected persons of high repute based on their community contribution, respect and honesty and same process is followed when removal is required. Panchayats proceedings are held in public where every member of community actively participates. Basically, Panchayat emphasizes on compensation and penalties instead of imprisonment which are interpreted in light of the traditional norms and cases do no linger on for years or months rather cases are decided are in a matter of days or rarely in weeks.