Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Personalized Screencast Feedback: Rethinking How We Respond to Student Writing

Sat, October 2, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Providing substantive written feedback on student writing is time-intensive, and the written comments faculty give students are often ambiguous, vulnerable to misinterpretation, and impersonal. In an effort to better utilize the limited and valuable time of our teaching faculty, and to make the feedback they provide their students more approachable, constructive, and intimate—and, therefore, more likely to be implemented by students in their revisions—this paper explores the promise of newer technologies for reviewing and commenting on student writing. Specifically, by utilizing screen-capture software and digital annotations (via stylus pen) of student writing, I explore the value of departing from traditional hand-written or typed comments on student papers and instead preparing brief screencasts that better engage students by creating a more intimate, conference-like experience. Not only do these screencasts provide students personalized feedback on their papers, which should give them the impression that their work and ideas are taken seriously by the faculty member—which rhetoric and composition scholars have argued better motivates students to invest in improving their writing—but offering verbal comments on student writing clarifies the faculty member’s tone and helps to avoid misinterpretations by students. Moreover, adopting these emerging classroom technologies helps to reduce the significant time it takes to carefully review student papers and provide substantive and constructive feedback.

To these ends, this paper presents the findings of a recent study of six sections of three different upper-division, writing-intensive courses, involving the review of 130 rough drafts of semester-long research projects. Each class had two sections, one of which served as the control group that received traditional typed comments, and the other served as the treatment group that received screencasts of their digitally-annotated drafts. In examining the variation across the sections in several key measures of critical-thinking skills—such as the cogency of starting assumptions, an understanding of standards of evidence, and the plausibility of objections and refutations—as well as several key measures of writing skills—such as providing adequate background for the target audience, effectively structuring the paper and offering clear transitions, and making successful rhetorical appeals—this working paper demonstrates the causal influence of personalized, screencast feedback on the quality of student research and writing. Further, this empirical analysis also suggests that students who receive this novel form of feedback on their drafts are more likely to be receptive to constructive criticism and substantively revise their final papers, which is one of the defining features of the maturation of student writers.

Author