Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Disaster by Design: Submersed Stakeholders & the Economy of Dam Failure

Sun, October 3, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

In the dark of night, a 5 billion cubic meter torrent of muddy water crashed through rooftops and ripped through the downstream villages of southeast Laos in July 2018. An auxiliary saddle dam collapsed in the $1.2 billion Xe Pian-Xe Namnoy hydropower project (PNPC) which had just reached financial close five years prior in 2013. In the aftermath of the collapse, official state narratives pointed to extreme rain weather conditions and ‘unforeseen’ construction and engineering miscalculations with regard to soil conditions. Alternatively, this paper examines the financial determinants of dam failure vis-a-vis rival explanations. It takes an interdisciplinary approach which triangulates between political economy, political ecology, geology and civil-hydrological engineering data to demonstrate the importance of cross-disciplinary triangulation in testing and challenging political narratives that seek to ‘naturalize’ and deflect accountability away from anthropogenic factors in disaster research. The paper discusses the fundamental paradigm shift from state-led dam building as a public good, to financialized dam building as an asset class for transnational investors since the end of the Cold War. Significantly, it sheds light on the serious public and environmental safety and policy implications posed by the re-engineering of contemporary dam finance. In the case of Lao PDR, the official response of the ruling one-party regime to the Namnoy collapse was to limit information and restrict international press access to affected areas in the aftermath of dam failure; they did not count the bodies and reveal the extent of casualty. In death as in life, the bodies and voices of dam communities counted for so little that they were discounted. This paper takes political stock and financial accounting of the spending, construction and operating decisions, timelines, and incentives which resulted in financially-designed disaster.

Authors