Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Legitimacy, Interests, and Knowledge: Rousseau's Elective Aristocracy

Sat, October 2, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

In the Social Contract, Rousseau radically critiques the prevailing political institutions of his day, but he also praises aristocracy as the best government. In investigating this apparent paradox, Rousseau’s passage on the historical genesis of aristocracies is particularly illuminating. It clarifies his views on the epistemic issues citizens face when they decide what kind of person should be eligible for magistracy, as well as how both self-interest and other, more sinister outside influences affect these decisions. I argue that the method of choosing magistrates determines not only a government’s form but also its legitimacy. Specifically, I demonstrate that for Rousseau, legitimate governments are rarer than expected. Because the government called elective aristocracy least restricts who is eligible for magistracy, it alone doesn’t mistake government power for sovereignty. Thus, only elective aristocracy, despite its faults, has the potential to be a truly good government.

Author