Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

A Dynamic Reassessment of the Asian-Values-Thesis

Sat, September 17, 3:30 to 4:00pm, TBA

Abstract

The Asian-values-thesis suggests that a key reason that East Asian societies have undertaken a distinct trajectory of development (as compared to the trajectory of Western democracies) is that the Confucian legacies have cast a heavy and long shadow over the region. Students of comparative politics have also developed their interest in examining this thesis since the late 1990s. Despite the accumulation of rich empirical evidence over the past decades, there is hardly any consensus regarding the validity of the Asian-values-thesis. On the one hand, a group of scholars has established interesting patterns of political attitudes and behaviors in East Asia (i.e., the premium of political trust, more reservations towards political conflicts, higher willingness to serve the public interest even at the cost of individual benefits, more emphasis on the instrumental values of democracy, etc.) that cannot be easily accommodated by related theories built upon the experiences of Western democracies. On the other hand, another group of scholars has found little evidence for the exceptionality of East Asia (i.e., poplar embracement of emancipative values, endorsement of democracy as the most desirable form of government, etc.), especially when examined in a much broader comparative context.
There are two key issues with the aforementioned scholarship, which might have prevented the scholars from engaging in a more fruitful dialogue. First, the key variable of interest (i.e., East Asia) has been operationalized and measured in distinct ways. For instance, scholars disagree over whether Mongolia and Kyrgyzstan should be counted as part of East Asia. Second, almost all pertinent research relies on the design of the cross-sectional analysis, without paying any attention to possible longitudinal dynamics involved. Therefore, some positive evidence might be secured using empirical data collected in the late 1990s; while some negative evidence might be established using empirical data collected in the early 2000s. Given the discrepancy in the operationalization of the key variable, as well as the overlooked possible longitudinal variation in underlying dynamics, it is no wonder that the scholarly debates regarding the Asian-values-thesis have not been effectively resolved. In this paper, we have proposed to address both issues and reassess the Asian-values-thesis using a dynamic framework.
Rather than using a cross-sectional design, we have collected the most comprehensive rolling cross-sectional survey data provided by the World Values Survey (WVS), from its second wave to its seventh wave for a dynamic examination. Basically, we have adopted a three-level hierarchical linear modeling strategy to integrate all six waves of WVS data for more efficient estimation and effective analysis. By simultaneously modeling the influence of societal-level differences (key to the Asian-values-thesis) and wave/period-specific impact on such influence (key to possible longitudinal dynamics), we can more effectively examine the validity of the Asian-values-thesis, as well as whether the validity might be challenged or reinforced as the region has witnessed dramatic socioeconomic and political transformations over the past decades.
Furthermore, we have tried to generate a more refined measure of “East Asia” by focusing on the historical legacies of Confucian traditions, as well as related geographical scope of influence. Theoretically, for the Asian-values-thesis to work, there should be significant social and political processes that have enabled the transmission and reservation of Confucian legacies (which originated from the Central Kingdom and later spread to surrounding societies). Rather than simply claiming that some societies are more Confucian than others, we want to generate a more refined measure that might capture the varying magnitude of the influence of Confucian traditions on a given society, by incorporating the findings of related historical scholarship. Politically, the key issue is the experience of a given society using civil-service examinations to recruit elites following the Chinese Keju model. Economically, the key issue is the experience of a given society engaging in the tributary system centered around the Central Kingdom. Culturally, the key issue is the experience of a given society sending delegates and students to the Central Kingdom for exchanges. For diaspora connections, the population size of overseas Chinese in a given society should be the key. With such a more refined measure of “East Asia”, we can systematically examine different versions of the Asian-values-thesis and tease out possible underlying mechanisms.
Overall, this paper should contribute to the existing scholarship on the Asian-values-thesis by providing a more refined measure of its key variable of interest and a more effective dynamic framework for evaluations. This should be of great value for students of both comparative politics and East Asian politics.

Authors