Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Public Preferences on Foreign Aid to Control Migration

Sat, September 17, 3:30 to 4:00pm, TBA

Abstract

Immigration control brings chaos and suffering into stark relief. In response, wealthy countries have increased the use of foreign aid with the expressed purpose of tackling the ‘root causes’ of migration. This policy promises to reduce the political costs of immigration control by both regulating flows and reducing visibility, and garners high levels of public support across the aisle: 85% of the US public agrees with pre-emptive immigration control, including 86% of Democrats and 87% of Republicans (Civiqs 2021). It is not surprising, therefore, that the Biden-Harris administration has wholeheartedly embraced the ‘root causes’ approach. However, this level of cross-ideological support for an electorate so divided on immigration suggests different people are seeing different moral and practical purposes in ‘root causes’ aid. Importantly, some people might view aid as a reason to reduce immigration, claiming that migrants do not need to migrate if they receive aid from the US government that increases their well-being. Others might see aid as a justification for increasing enforcement against migrants arriving from aid-receiving countries, claiming such migrants have less reason to migrate if they are recipients of aid. Still others might feel that aid is an alternative to violent enforcement, a way to reduce inward migration without the need for deportations and force along the border.

Despite the apparent complexity of public support for root causes aid, there is little public opinion research on the matter. We ask (1) what drives support for root causes aid; and (2) what are its knock-on effects on immigration policy preferences? In particular, we aim to assess whether citizens are more likely to support reducing the number of visas provided to migrants if greater aid is granted to the countries migrants arrive from, and whether support for aid is tied to support for reductions in migration in general.

To assess these questions, we implement a factorial vignette experiment in the United States (N=3,000) to examine whether support for aid varies depending on the presence of coercive immigration enforcement, and whether subjects are more likely to support aid if the aid is effective at decreasing inward migration. We are particularly interested in evaluating whether those who are anti-immigrant are more likely to make their support for aid conditional on this aid deterring future migration.

Behind the apparent cross-ideological consensus, we expect sharp differences in support. By design, aid intending to deter migration is intended to help states fulfil their humanitarian duties to the poor without allowing greater migration. As such, we expect significant knock-on effects on immigration policy preferences.

Authors