Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Topic
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Deadlines
Policies
Updating Your Submission
Requesting AV
Presentation Tips
Request a Visa Letter
FAQs
X (Twitter)
Search Tips
Annual Meeting App
About Annual Meeting
This paper examines the consequences of the shift in the nation’s overall approach to immigration enforcement from one focused primarily on unauthorized entrants and border security to the interior enforcement of unauthorized immigrants in collaboration with state and local law enforcement agencies. The interoperability of federal immigration authorities and local law enforcement through programs like 287(g) and Secure Communities has rendered the threat of immigration enforcement omnipresent but never certain. Thus, immigrant illegality is structured by the ubiquity—and uncertainty—of enforcement in everyday life. Although De Genova (2002) has theorized the role of deportation in structuring immigrant illegality, I argue that illegality is structured not only through the threat of deportation, but through a constellation of potential consequences resulting from the devolution of immigration enforcement. Since any interaction with a member of law enforcement could reasonably—though not necessarily—result in an unauthorized immigrant’s detention and eventual removal, the enforcement of immigration law appears analogous to a lottery system, a seemingly random process whose outcome is ostensibly determined by the arbitrariness of chance or luck. Drawing on more than two years of participatory ethnographic research with immigrant rights actors in Alabama, Georgia, and Tennessee, I theorize an enforcement lottery, which relentlessly threatens unauthorized immigrants with the consequences of detection, discretion, detention, and deportation. This lottery is a system of control, and it serves to perpetuate the vulnerability of the unauthorized through the everyday threat of illegality.