Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Why Fathers Fall Short: Using Identity Processes to Understand Persistent Inequality in Parenting

Sun, August 17, 10:30am to 12:10pm, TBA

Abstract

In this paper we address an oversight in identity theory – identity processes in situations that lack widely-shared and stable cultural expectations – by exploring the experiences of fathers in the contemporary context. Using data from in-depth interviews, collected as part of the Time, Love, and Cash in Couples with Children (TLC3) study, we find that the less clear a conception about what makes a good father is, the more difficult it is for a father to experience identity self-verification. We contrast fathers who have abstract or conditional definitions of fatherhood with fathers who have clear, specific definitions, and find that fathers who lack well-defined identity expectations experience negative consequences. These men engage in less caretaking within the family, have less fulfilling relationships with their partners and children, and suffer from a lack of self-verification as good fathers. We outline the implications of this disjuncture between the culture and conduct of fatherhood, and the related inequality in household divisions of labor, in light of these results.

Authors