Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Keeping Practitioners Engaged: Interpreting Failure, Sustaining Commitment and Cultivating the Spiritual Self

Tue, August 19, 10:30am to 12:10pm, TBA

Abstract

Perceived failures and shortcomings abound in the process of spiritual formation: spiritual experiences are few and far between, progress is difficult to perceive and evaluate, and the lofty ideals of the aspired-to spiritual identity are (by definition) unachievable for the majority of practitioners. In addition, training programs in spiritual disciplines – intentional practices, such as yoga and meditation, which require regular and sustained commitment and are said to facilitate spiritual formation – often explicitly encourage practitioners to identify and acknowledge their failures and shortcomings. Research suggests that individuals tend to abandon tasks in the face of repeated failures. Given this, how do organizations and instructors encourage continued engagement in spiritual disciplines despite repeated failures? Applying key insights from research on motivation, commitment and identification, and drawing on case studies of two organizations offering training programs in spiritual disciplines – a Catholic Prayer House and an Integral Yoga Institute – I argue that the way these communities deal with failure, practically and discursively, promotes persistence in several ways. First, the explicit emphasis on failure can be interpreted as a process of mortification which encourages ego-detachment and increases commitment to the group’s beliefs and practices. In addition, discourses which normalize and valorize failure retrain practitioners’ attributions and promote the development of self-compassion, decreasing the likelihood of avoidance-coping strategies. Finally, regular occasions of collective sharing provide spaces for modeling success and social persuasion, promoting feelings of efficacy among practitioners. I discuss the implications of these findings for behavioral modification, more broadly.

Author