Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Broken Windows as Growth Machines: Who Benefits from Urban Disorder?

Tue, August 14, 8:30 to 10:10am, Pennsylvania Convention Center, Floor: Level 100, 113A

Abstract

Using interview data from two distinct groups in the Woodlawn neighborhood on the South Side of Chicago—mothers of young children and neighborhood merchants—this paper suggests that a preoccupation with social disorder and crime has distracted urban scholars from recognizing that some signs of physical disorder can serve as a different type of sign: one of development potential in a neighborhood primed for gentrification. The paper offers a new paradigm for thinking about these issues called the opportunistic disorder paradigm, which is contrasted with both the broken windows paradigm and the neighborhood effects paradigm. The paper then examines the historical and contemporary role of one stakeholder in Woodlawn—Apostolic Church of God—as an illustration of this new perspective. Making connections between physical disorder and social disorder is not necessarily wrong—such perceptions are real enough, not just among urbanists, but also among neighborhood residents. However, by focusing only on the experiential and reputational aspects of vacant lots, we miss what they can mean from a financial perspective. By focusing only on disorder and crime, and not on economic opportunity, we lose sight of the question “Who benefits from the way things are?” This paper demonstrates that disorder and crime, and the reputation for it embodied by vacant lots and abandoned buildings, can be and are used as effective tools of urban development. In other words, broken windows (Wilson and Kelling 1982) enter the service of the growth machine (Logan and Molotch 1987).

Author