Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Gendered Payoffs to Being an "Ideal Worker"

Tue, August 14, 10:30am to 12:10pm, Philadelphia Marriott Downtown, Floor: Level 5, Salon H

Abstract

Ideal worker norms place high expectations on employees to be completed devoted to their work and free from other entangling obligations. Though seemingly gender-neutral, these norms are in fact highly gendered, often in tension with cultural expectations of women in the home and family, and tied to expressions of masculinity and fatherhood for men. Research has shown that the gendered nature of ideal worker norms shapes the likelihood that men and women engage in practices such as working long hours or taking leave, but less is known about how these norms interact with gender to shape perceptions of employees as well as workplace outcomes such as pay and promotions. Do men and women experience the same outcomes for meeting or failing to meet ideal work norms? Though a great deal of qualitative work as well as some experimental evidence outlines potential differences in how signals of ideal worker norms are understood based on gender, a good deal of quantitative work has failed to find significant interactions, perhaps due to unobserved differences in worker quality. The goal of this study is to integrate insights provided by prior scholarship in order to assess the ways in which gender might shape perceptions of work hours and the consequences of meeting or failing to meet ideal worker norms using experimental manipulations. Results of a pilot experiment find that women who engage in overwork, particularly in male-dominated fields, are viewed as less competent compared to women who work an average number of hours, while men face no such penalty.

Author