Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Gender and Legitimacy in Professionalized Service Occupations: The Case of Alternative Death Care

Sat, August 11, 8:30 to 10:10am, Philadelphia Marriott Downtown, Floor: Level 5, Salon H

Abstract

End of life doulas and death midwives are part of a growing sector of personal service occupations that include jobs such as life coach and personal concierge. These jobs are feminized in the sense that they are sought out and performed primarily by women and entail the commodification of women’s previously unpaid work. Previous research highlights how feminized narratives about personalized service work can undermine members’ efforts to secure occupational legitimacy. Because professionalization relies on the construction of expertise through abstract knowledge and standardized training, scholars find that women hinder their own professionalization projects when they frame their work in terms of natural talent, intuition, and other qualities implicitly coded as feminine. In this paper, I examine the professionalization narratives of 17 pioneers in alternative death care, looking specifically at the gendered quality of those narratives. I find that, as previous research suggests, feminized discourse operates in tension with professionalization, potentially undermining women’s efforts to garner legitimacy for their work. At the same time, I find that women deploy such narratives because they capture what they see as the underlying purpose of their occupation: heart-centered, intimate, anti-industrial care. This research suggests that, in the post-modern marketplace where customized service, authenticity, and self-actualization are highly valued commodities, some actors see feminized narratives as an asset, not just a liability.

Author