Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Settler Colonialism and the Era of Neomodernization in Water Management

Sat, August 11, 8:30 to 9:30am, Philadelphia Marriott Downtown, Floor: Level 5, Salon G

Abstract

This paper uses analysis of three cases in North American and the Middle East to argue that the re(turn) to large water infrastructure can be at least partly explained as an effort to save settler colonial modernization of landscapes. We use a combined political ecology and settler colonial studies framework that emphasizes historical-geographic materialism to compare the cases of the canal between Red Sea and Dead Sea (the, so called Red-Dead Canal) jointly implemented by Israel and Jordan; and the Missouri River Diversion in the United States Great Plains. We find that while there are important contextual differences, the cases have remarkable similarities. Both are expensive technical fixes for socio-environmental crises to have emerged as a result of water diversion and abstraction as part of the settler colonial process. But, likewise, both purport to provide environmental benefits that could not otherwise be achieved. While these cases represent a return to large infrastructure, the mechanisms through which they mobilize and distribute financial and built capital is different from the infrastructure initiatives of the mid-20th century. These initiatives implicate non-state actors to a far greater extent. Lastly, in both cases, potential problems that are likely to emerge over time are already identified.

Authors