Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Session Type
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Deadlines
Policies
Updating Your Submission
Accessible Presentation
FAQs
X (Twitter)
Search Tips
About Annual Meeting
In this paper, we describe two dominant theories for understanding the current ecological crisis as well as prescribing solutions, reflexive modernity and critical social metabolism. We base our description on the principal mechanisms each theory utilizes to explain how the current social structure leads to the production of ecological risk and risk adaptation. We then utilize critical social metabolism to challenge the theoretical mechanisms proposed by reflexive modernity, which are reliant on institutional adaptation while maintaining the current social structure. Further, we challenge their proposed social agents to carry out this institutional reflexivity as the very same agents demonstrating a problematic anti-reflexivity leading to increased risks, and thus a deepening of the crisis. Following critical social metabolism, we consider the current social structure a capitalist social metabolic order, whereby the social-ecological relation is dominated by commodification. While reflexive modernity argues that commodification produces risks, it also argues that further commodification will resolve ecological risks. Critical social metabolic analysis also argues commodification plays a principal role in producing ecological risks that bring about our current ecological crisis, but in contradistinction to reflexive modernity does not find evidence for commodification’s capacity to resolve ecological risk through institutional adoption of ecological rationality. Rather, critical social metabolic scholars consider resolution of capitalist ecological risk to be possible through the development of class power able to transition to another social metabolic order. That is, rather than being an institutional problem resolved by reliance on corporate and state actors, as proposed by reflexive modernization scholars, the ecological crisis is fundamentally a political conflict based on the role of class as a determinant of production. We rely on a bibliographical review of current literature from both traditions to make our argument, drawing from theoretical and empirical works.