Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Moral Economy of Quantification Devices: Factoring Class Inequality into School Valuation in Chile

Tue, August 14, 10:30am to 12:10pm, Philadelphia Marriott Downtown, Floor: Level 4, Franklin Hall 12

Abstract

Building on the sociology of quantification and valuation, I investigate the morally charged use of statistical devices in the implementation of high-stakes accountability regulation in Chilean education. I focus on the so-called School Ordinalization Methodology (SOM), an assessment technology set out to hold providers (schools) responsible to consumers (students) and thus perform socially optimal market outcomes (e.g., that all schools provide quality education). When devising the best method to commensurate the quality of all Chilean K-12 schools with a single ordinal metric, policymakers confronted a moral conundrum: should schools be valued according to their students’ absolute proficiency, or for the organization’ relative effectiveness? My analysis reveals that progressive and conservative technocrats in charge of operationalizing the legal mandate that students’ socioeconomic characteristic be factored into school assessments clashed over two opposed conceptions of “quality” and “fairness”. While the former invoked justice in relation to providers (schools) for the sake of a fair distribution of responsibility for educating “socially diverse” students, the latter, less suspicious of proficiency rankings, conceived justice on behalf of consumers (students), understanding quality irrespective of the school’s relative contribution. Unable to address this dilemma openly, however, technocrats reduced it to the selection of the statistical model that yield ranking distributions that better fit their moral preferences, taking a vote between ordinary least squares and hierarchical linear models. I argue that the way experts aligned in this vote epitomizes the surreptitious ideological dispute over the role of the SOM in the legitimation of the actually existing, class-segregated market order. But I also claim that reducing incommensurable notions of “quality” and “fairness” to a technical procedure of statistical adjustment allowed anti- and pro-market experts to conceal their ideological disagreement: a depoliticizing effect generally overlooked by research on the “performativity” of market devices.

Author