Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Weekend Birth Dearth: Reproductive Regimes and Provider Efficiency versus Evidence-Based Maternity Care

Tue, August 11, 8:30 to 9:30am PDT (8:30 to 9:30am PDT), Hilton San Francisco Union Square, Floor: Ballroom Level, Imperial A

Abstract

In maternity care, there is a tension between evidence-based best practices and organizational efficiency. The medical model of childbirth dominates hospital births, whereby physicians intervene into labor and birth in an attempt to fit all labors into a standard timetable and control the birth process. However, evidence-based based practices for pregnancies without obstetric complications include a low-intervention midwifery model of care. In this paper, I examine the effects of the legal environment on the odds of a weekend birth. I argue that the odds of a birth occurring on a weekend should be lower in provider-friendly states with tort reforms that reduce providers’ liability risk, compared to patient-friendly states where the risk of liability is higher. The odds of a weekend birth should also be lower in states with fetus-centered reproductive rights laws that give physicians more authority over maternity care decisions than pregnant women, compared to woman-centered reproductive rights regimes. I use multi-level logistic models (MLLM) to examine the effects of state-level tort and reproductive rights laws on the odds of a birth occurring on a weekend from 1995-2015. I find that the odds of a weekend birth are, in fact, lower when states have tort reforms and when they have more restrictions on reproductive rights. The findings support the argument that interventions that benefit providers are more common in provider-friendly tort regimes and fetus-centered reproductive rights regimes.

Author