Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

‘It Becomes a Crutch’: A Sociomaterial Exploration of Wearable Cameras in Police Organizations

Fri, Nov 16, 2:00 to 3:20pm, Marriott, L503, Lobby Level

Abstract

This paper contributes to body camera research by considering how it affects police organization. Drawing from the information systems and management literature on sociomateriality (Orlikowski and Scott 2008), it explores the materiality, social construction, and emergent properties of BWCs. To do this, it shares findings from a first-wave of research consisting of 34 semi-structured interviews with police leaders, supervisors, and patrol officers from five departments in the Western United States. With regard to materiality, the paper finds that BWCs both enable and constrain existing police operations—for instance, they bolster process efficiency by enhancing reporting capability and accessibility to evidence, but digital visibility can miss wrongdoing the human eye captures. The performance of camera systems is, in turn, influenced by social arrangements—activation policies and protocols for labeling footage, for instance, affect whether the technology actually captures the interactions they were intended to. The introduction of body cameras into police organizations also produces emergent phenomena, as officers bemoan a perceived loss of trust with cameras and vendors increase their influence upon procurement and data management processes in policing. The implications of sociomaterial thinking for future research on BWCs and policing technology in general are considered.

Authors