Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Impact of Perceived Authority on Juror Decision-Making During Deliberations: An Experimental Design

Thu, Nov 15, 7:15 to 8:15pm, Marriott, Atrium B, Atrium Level

Abstract

This study aimed to examine the effect of authority on jury deliberations using an experimental design. Jury deliberations are one of the most important aspects of a court case, and it is important to determine if varying levels of authority impact the statements and votes of jurors. Experiments in criminology have shown the impact of authority figures on witness statements, often inducing inaccurate testimony as a result. This study examined pre- to post-test change in jurors’ statements based on varying levels of perceived authority in a deliberation scenario. Study confederates, representing varying levels of authority, were present and aimed to influence participants to change certain answers to the incorrect response during their deliberations process. The confederates were of three levels of authority: low (undergraduate student peer), medium (PhD student in criminology), and high (former FBI agent), as well as a control group with no authority figure. It was hypothesized that the higher authority condition will have more participants change observation responses from correct to incorrect, in alignment with the authority, compared to the lower authority conditions. Results indicated that the peer group had the biggest influence on the participants, who were all college students. Implications of this study are discussed.

Authors