Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Poster #67 - The Effect of Co-witness Contamination and Investigator Bias on Juror Perceptions of Eyewitness Testimonies

Thu, Nov 19, 6:30 to 7:30pm, Adams Room - Posters 1 - 79 - 6th Floor

Abstract

Mistaken eyewitness identifications are a significant contributor to wrongful convictions, particularly in cases involving multiple eyewitnesses. Although prior research shows that eyewitness memory is vulnerable to social influence, less is known about how jurors evaluate testimonies exposed to social contagion. The present study examines how co-witness contamination and investigator blindness shape juror decision-making and perceptions of eyewitness evidence. Using a 2 × 2 between-subjects experimental design, participants were randomly assigned to one of four conditions manipulating co-witness contamination (independent vs. dependent testimony) and investigator blindness (single-blind vs. double-blind lineup administration). Participants were asked to read a mock trial stimulus and complete a questionnaire assessing verdict decisions, confidence levels, perceived defendant guilt, and testimony quality. Six planned comparisons will test whether jurors were able to distinguish between stronger and weaker eyewitness evidence. It is expected that jurors will render more guilty verdicts and report higher perceptions of guilt and evidence quality when co-witnesses are independent and lineups are double-blind, with the strongest effects in the double-blind independent condition and the weakest in the single-blind dependent condition. Findings will clarify whether jurors appropriately weigh eyewitness reliability and may inform procedural reforms, judicial instructions, and expert testimony practices aimed at reducing wrongful convictions.

Authors