Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Poster #122 - An Exploratory Analysis of Arrest Histories among Participant in Illinois Police-Initiated Deflection Programs

Thu, Nov 19, 7:30 to 8:45pm, Monroe Room - Posters 80 - 155 - 6th Floor

Abstract

Police deflection programs aim to reduce justice system involvement by connecting individuals at risk of arrest with social services and treatment; however, it remains unclear whether participants have substantial prior arrest histories or represent individuals with minimal risk of police contact. This study presents an exploratory analysis of arrest histories among participants in police-initiated deflection programs. The primary objectives are to better understand the population served by these programs and to assess the appropriateness of arrest as an outcome measure. This distinction is central to an ongoing debate in the deflection literature regarding whether such programs reduce arrests or primarily serve individuals unlikely to be arrested.

Using criminal history record information, this study examines the prevalence, frequency, and severity of participants’ prior arrests. Findings will inform whether arrest and recidivism are meaningful outcomes for evaluating program effectiveness. If participants exhibit significant prior justice system involvement, arrest outcomes may be appropriate for certain populations. Conversely, limited or low-level arrest histories may suggest prioritizing alternative outcomes, such as treatment engagement, housing stability, or quality of life measures. This study contributes both to the evaluation of Illinois’ statewide deflection initiative and to broader efforts to refine outcome measurement in deflection research.

Authors