Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
If the world is indeed becoming ‘smaller,’ as the commonplace suggests, the opportunities to reach out to colleagues in professional discourse should be employed. The resulting shared visions and conversations should, in turn, be put into practice and examined for effectiveness and practicality. This is no less appropriate for education and teacher preparation as it is for other fields of study and endeavor. Comparing purpose, pedagogical assumption, implementation and assessment ideology in connection with results should only serve to reaffirm or debilitate national, state, and local educational practices. Von Kopp (2010) suggests that comparative education is by nature “border crossing” and, when viewed in that context, it remains favorable for snapshots of theory, research, and practice.
There is currently a great deal of imploring for the need for comparative education in a globalized society. Schleicher (2011) emphasizes that comparative education has the capacity to enable nations to set measurable goals by considering the structure and accomplishments of other nations, and to ascertain the process and practicality of their own system. Globalization has the potential to promote convergence and standardization in education across geographic and political boundaries.
Ultimately, engaging in comparative education dialog with colleagues in global contemporary education systems serves two purposes. First, it enables one assembly to reflect on the practices and effectiveness of their own system and make decisions, both in policy making and in pedagogy, to enhance their educational praxis. Second, participation in global colloquy provides opportunity to transcend ethnocentrism and assist colleagues in their assessment of their own systems. While these two purposes are certainly important and potentially impactful, how does it happen that colleagues are able to exchange ideas and assess the practice of others? It is one thing for policy makers to discuss pedagogy and philosophy, but how will that translate into practice? If global dialogs are meant to be influential, the importance of those directly affected (that is, teachers) cannot be understated; this is how effectiveness and practicality are examined. This paper describes the collaboration between an American university and a regional ministry of education in the Russian Federation in an attempt to bridge the cultural gap between two nations and promote effective teaching in public schools. The collaboration was considered to be a pilot project in order to evaluate feasibility, time, cost, adverse effects, and design.
Sam Houston State University (SHSU) in Huntsville, Texas and the Ministry of Education, Science, and Youth Policy of the Komi Republic in the Russian Federation partnered in June of 2018 to provide professional development for teachers in the Komi Republic. SHSU faculty had previously participated in professional development for teachers in the Republic through Skype in the fall of 2017. This time, however, faculty traveled to the Republic with students in the SHSU Comparative and Global Education graduate program to help provide professional development during a two-day conference. The three students, each a teacher in public schools in Texas, designed and provided for Russian teachers sessions that corresponded with their particular area of interest and experience. The SHSU faculty, along with members of the Ministry, provided sessions as well. Session topics included the use of modern information technologies in education, the implementation of professional learning communities, civic education, project-based learning, and the challenge of inter-cultural communication in education. Over the course of the conference, 31 sessions were offered for educators and representatives from SHSU were involved in 16 of the sessions.
Presenters and participants were surveyed afterwards to help determine the extent of success in helping to make teachers more effective in the classroom and the degree to which cultural understanding had occurred. As of this writing, the results among teachers in Russia were still being compiled. When the data is finalized, we plan on reporting on the impact that the international professional development had on both the practices and attitudes of Russian teachers and American presenters. Certainly, preliminary anecdotal reports gathered from all groups were positive and suggest a continuation of the practice be considered.
This particular project was designed with a post-conference survey specifically for participants and a survey specifically for the presenters from SHSU. In this way, it was hoped to gage perceptions as to attitude towards the practice of international professional development and potential effectiveness of information/skills presented at the conference. In the future, we would suggest using not only a post-conference survey, but also a follow-up survey of participants to determine if information/skills gathered during the conference were used in instructional practice or pedagogical foundations. In this way, effectiveness and practicality may be examined. Another consideration for the future involves the location of the professional development. The Russian Federation has been under Level 3 Travel Advisory status as determined by the United States Department of State; that is, “Reconsider Travel.” This status made the SHSU administration reluctant to allow the students to represent the university or to fund part of their trip. Determining another possible location is a very real consideration for those reasons.
Presenting at CIES will allow us to report on our efforts in order to solicit suggestions from colleagues. It is hoped this will be a catalyst for further collaborations.
William Douglas Edgington, Sam Houston State University
Galina Kitaygorodskaya, Ministry of Education, Science, and Youth Policy of the Komi Republic
Natalia Novokova, Syktyvkar State University