Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
STATEMENT OF PURPOSE
This paper presents a systematic review of the articles published about school level leadership and administration in 8 key comparative education journals from 1995-2018. The purpose of the paper is to demonstrate that, as a field, comparative education engages questions of school level leadership and administration at best unevenly. This absence is especially noteworthy since during the dates covered by the review the school principalship was embraced as a lever for school improvement and school reform worldwide (Schleicher 2012; Day et al. 2016; OECD, 2016). In an attempt to understand what our database of 87 articles indicates about the fields of educational administration and comparative education we also inductively developed a new conceptual framework.
RELEVANT LITERATURE
We begin by noting the growing call in educational administration for more international and comparative perspectives. Pashiardis and Johansson (2016) have argued that “it is increasingly obvious that more research concerning the needs of educational leaders within a specific cultural context is definitely necessary in order to prepare successful and effective school leaders’ (p. 12). Harris et al., (2016) have likewise cautioned against blind policy borrowing from one country to another, noting that what counts as successful leadership will always be “culturally and contextually defined” (p. 8). Part of the challenge developing these contextual understandings is the fact that, as Bush (2014) has argued, “the literature on educational leadership and management is dominated by authors from the United States, United Kingdom and Australia” (p. 787), meaning local perspectives on educational administration are underrepresented for most of the globe. As Harris and Jones (2015) put it, “Authentic comparative studies are imperative, if the voices of those working in very different countries, contexts and diverse educational settings are to be heard and most importantly, recognized” (p. 316).
Twenty years ago, Dimmock and Walker (1998) critiqued the field of educational administration for the “relative absence of cross-cultural analyses of school-level studies concerning leadership, management, and organization” (p. 559) and called for “mapping a distinctive territory of comparative educational administration” (p. 560). Given the growing number of calls for comparative, international studies of school level leadership in distinctive contexts, it appears that Dimmock and Walker’s vision has yet to be achieved. The significance is twofold: first, school level organizational management in vast regions of the world are underrepresented in the scholarly literature; second, when regions outside the “anglosphere” are represented in the literature, they frequently rely on that very same research literature, regardless of the appropriateness of the comparison.
The field of comparative education seems like the right place to turn for a more contextually-rich study of school leadership. However, the attention paid to school leadership in comparative education is scant. Foster, Addy and Samoff (2012) reviewed 605 articles published in four major comparative education journals from 2004-2008 and concluded “the economic, political, and social context of education receives far more attention than its content” (p. 711). Furthermore, they illustrated that “some topics received little attention from researchers, with the fewest mentions across the journals including inspectorate (less than 1%); administration and leadership (1% each), and evaluation/ research (2%)” (Foster, Addy & Samoff, 2012, p. 717). Furthermore, Raby (2010) analyzed the 2009 Comparative Education Review bibliography, and showed that educational leadership is not one of the most prominent themes in the field (maximum 34 articles, in 2009). By comparison, more prominent themes included higher education (230), secondary and youth education (112), Teacher education (119), Gender and sexual orientation (147) and Minority, refugee and immigrant education (113).
METHODOLOGY
We conducted a systematic review of the literature: “a review of the research literature using systematic and explicit, accountable methods” (Gough, Oliver & Thomas, 2012, p. 2). We first defined our research question: What are the conceptual and empirical trends in the comparative education field’s examination of school level leadership since 1995? We selected eight journals that are published in English, well known in the field of comparative education, widely read and reputable, and peer reviewed. We did not include publications that would be considered “gray literature,” such as work from UNESCO or the World Bank.
In online databases, we searched each journal separately, using the following search string leader* OR principal* OR manage* and searching only in the title. Our search brought up a total of 204 studies, of which we selected 87 based on a review of titles and abstracts, and in some unclear cases, a review of the article.
DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
We first reviewed multiple previously published analytical frameworks on school leadership and education management. Frameworks developed by Hallinger and Leithwood (1996), Dimmock and Walker (1998), and Wang, Bowers & Fikis (2017) were the most relevant for our review. We made a first attempt to categorize the articles into those chosen frameworks using Excel spreadsheets by journal. However, this proved unfruitful given the diversity of ways that school leadership is approached in the articles in our database. Rather than misapply a borrowed framework in ways that Harris and colleagues (2016) have warned against, it became evident there was a need to develop an analytical framework for comparative educational administration. We created the categories inductively based on a review of all articles. Our final categorization is described in the new framework explained below.
EMERGENT FINDINGS AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF A NEW FRAMEWORK
Our findings include bibliographical patterns, main themes and the development of a new framework. In terms of bibliographical patterns, for this proposal, we show trends in years of publication and trends in studies per country. There are three spikes in publications, which coincide with Special Issues on School Leadership in the years 2000, 2009 and 2015. In terms of education systems, the three most prevalent are Hong Kong, China and Israel.
Overall, across the 23-year period 10 major topics on school leadership emerge in the comparative education literature: becoming a principal; training and preparation, principals’ practice (roles and styles); student outcomes; evaluation; succession; identity and career path; organizational structure and culture; societal culture and context; global ideas and culture.
Using these topics we developed a conceptual framework that shows the relationships between them. We identified three different contextual layers that influence the different stages/aspects of school principal profession. A first layer is related to the organizational culture and context of schools, a second one is related to the larger social and cultural context countrywide and finally the most external layer has to do with global ideas and culture influencing all other layers.
PRELIMINARY DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
The universe of publications on educational administration in comparative education journals is surprisingly small: an average of less than one research article per year for the majority of journals in our set. Said another way: If all you knew about school level leadership and administration came from what you could glean from the comparative education journals, you would have a disparate and shallow understanding of the field.
Why does this relative lack of emphasis on school level administration in comparative education matter? A connection between the fields of comparative education and educational administration would likely be mutually beneficial: the growing interest in international, more contextually based studies of school leadership would benefit from engagement with the theoretical knowledge base from comparative education. Furthermore, the contextually rich, geographically diverse studies of schooling found comparative education could benefit from the deep knowledge of school level leadership, policy implementation, and organizational development found in educational administration. Given the global growth of the education sector and a shared aspiration for improved schooling outcomes, more scholarship from comparativists who focus on school level administration seems warranted.
Joseph Flessa, OISE, University of Toronto
Gisele Cuglievan Mindreau, OISE University of Toronto
Daniela Bramwell, University of Toronto