Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
With increasing international mobility, greater inter-connectedness through social media, issues of climate change, and the rise of the global knowledge economy, expanding the horizon of educational opportunity is an issue that extends beyond national borders. Yet much of education policy-making and curriculum development has historically been conducted at the national level, or in cases such as the United States, on a State by State basis. Exploring the intersection of these two trends in education --one national in scope, the other transcending the national context-is becoming an increasingly complex and interesting endeavor. An examination of the emerging concept of global competence provides a particularly useful avenue to explore this pivotal intersection and its related effects for education in the 21st century.
Global competence has been articulated as a lifelong learning goal that enables learners to examine “local, global and intercultural issues, understand and appreciate different perspectives and world views, interact successfully and respectfully with others, and take responsible action toward sustainability and collective well-being” (Schleicher, 2017, np). Yet competences in general, and global competence in particular, can be framed in different ways. From a human capital perspective, competences are conceptualized as the essential mechanism through which education (schooling) produces effective workers for the global economy. Alternatively, a more rights-centric perspective conceptualizes competences as the core building blocks of education for more peaceful, just, and sustainable future societies (Bajaj, 2015).
In this paper, I endeavor to investigate the construction of competence as global through a comparative theoretical perspective. Drawing on scholarship in the fields of comparative and international education, global education policy, and critical internationalization, this paper presents a comparative analysis of three conceptual frames that scholars have employed to theorize the relationship between global policy trends and educational developments across different locations and scales. The first of these frameworks is Bernstein’s (2000) work on recontextualization and pedagogic identity which has been used by many comparative education scholars including, importantly, Robertson (2011) on the spatial politics of education policy-making, and more recently, Cobb and Couch (2018) in their critical analysis of the PISA 2018 global competence assessment. The second framework is Paulston’s (2000) work on social cartographies which has recently been employed by Andreotti, Stein, Pashby, and Nicolson (2016) to map and re-think the discursive terrain of higher education internationalization. The third theoretical lens is Schmidt’s (2008) work on discursive institutionalism which has been employed by Nordin and Sundberg (2016) to analyze the conceptual turn towards competence-based education in Europe and beyond. Additionally, the work of Sellar and Lingard (2014) on epistemological governance will be considered in this analysis.
Ultimately, this paper aims to provide scholars and other education stakeholders with tools that can be used to actively engage in a process of strategic de-coupling – that is – creating a purposeful de-alignment between the concept of global competence as it has been constructed by the OECD and alternative conceptualizations of competence as a component of critical global education. Implications for educational policy-making and practice will also be discussed.