Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Diversity in Asian American communities and their educational outcomes: a cultural and structural co-ethnic model

Tue, April 16, 10:00 to 11:30am, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific B

Proposal

Relevance of Topic
This is a theoretical and comparative paper that challenges the monolithic view of Asian Americans (AA) and examines diversity in 11 different AA communities and their educational outcomes. It presents a review of literature and census data and proposes a new theoretical framework to understand how cultural and structural factors of an ethnic group upon immigration to a new country shape its co-ethnic community development (strong, weak, or dispersed), and subsequently influence their later group outcomes, such as academic achievement. The paper highlights the link between culture, structure, co-ethnic community and education, by examining the differences and similarities in such characteristics of higher- and lower-achieving AA communities.

The paper includes the following major AA groups and subgroups: East Asians (Chinese, Korean, Japanese); South Asians (Indian, Pakistani, Bangladeshi); Southeast Asians (Vietnamese, Cambodian, Hmong, Laotian); and Filipinos. A literature review and census data help describe key cultural and structural characteristics of the diverse AA communities. The theoretical model is used to characterize the type of co-ethnic community for each AA group. Using this information, the authors systematically compare the cultural and structural characteristics as well as co-ethnic community types of higher- versus lower-achieving AA communities to help explain differences in educational outcomes among immigrant groups.

Theoretical Framework
This paper proposes a new theoretical framework, “Cultural and Structural Co-ethnic Model,” which is based on the earlier works of Paik et al. (2014) on diverse co-ethnic communities, Portes and Rumbaut’s (1990, 2001) theory on modes of incorporation, Zhou and Kim’s (2006) cultural and structural lens on ethnic social structures, and Coleman’s (1990) theory to understand social capital within ethnic communities. Many researchers take either a cultural or structural view to explain the economic and educational successes of ethnic minority groups. Zhou and Kim (2006) proposed combining both of these views, arguing that cultural characteristics need to be supported by structural factors to generate resources for upward mobility. Zhou and Kim regarded the ethnic community, a concept further developed by Portes and Rumbaut (1990, 2001), as a particular site in which culture and structure interact. The authors of this paper combine all these theories to explain how cultural factors (i.e., values, beliefs, and behaviors from the homeland) interact with structural factors (i.e., socio-economic status, immigration context, immigration selectivity) in different types of co-ethnic communities. These produce varying ethnic social capital for immigrant groups which all eventually impact employment and educational outcomes. It should also be noted that the model does not propose a direct quantitative link between culture, structure, co-ethnic community and education, but rather offers a general overview of what characteristics of an ethnic community tend to support educational success.

Literature Review
This paper uses a substantive review of literature and census data to compare cultural, structural, and co-ethnic community characteristics as well as educational outcomes of 11 different Asian American groups in one collective work. Typically, other works on AA groups have either looked at only East Asian Americans when studying AAs, or compared AAs at the macro level instead of considering subgroup differences, or focused on only two or three AA subgroups. The literature review presents demographics and key cultural and structural characteristics of the 11 AA groups, including unique traditions, parenting practices, religion, occupational outcomes and educational outcomes. It specifies the various types of co-ethnic communities (strong, dispersed or weak) and the resources and opportunities (ethnic social capital) they offer for each AA group. Based on this information, we begin seeing patterns in the characteristics of culture, structure and co-ethnic networks that are prevalent in higher- and lower-achieving communities.

Implications
This study is important and timely because the AA immigrant population has recently been identified as the fastest growing racial population in the United States (Pew Research Center, 2012). It challenges the misconception that AAs are a homogeneous group of model minority students, when there is wide diversity in educational attainment levels of particular ethnic groups. While this study systematically examined the similarities and differences across AA populations, more research needs to be conducted and disaggregated on these populations. As AA populations continue to grow in the U.S., it is important for educators and other helping professionals to have cultural knowledge and awareness on these groups. By understanding the characteristics of both higher- and lower-achieving co-ethnic communities and their ethnic social structures, educators and researchers can better understand access, resources, and opportunities of diverse AA communities. Moreover, parents, community members, helping professionals, and other stakeholders can work together to stabilize the efforts of struggling AA communities. Co-ethnic communities and ethnic social structures are important sources of ethnic social capital that can support economic and educational outcomes.

Additionally, we argue that a combined cultural and structural lens provides a more comprehensive understanding of an ethnic group’s immigration experiences and outcomes. Both perspectives support and interact with each other to create circumstances for immigrant groups.

Significance of the Study
The major contributions of this paper are its offer of a new and unique holistic theoretical model to understand immigrant adjustment processes and group outcomes, and its movement to disaggregate information on AAs. Unlike most studies, which either focus on the aggregate AA population or one subgroup, this paper examines diverse groups in one collective work to gain a holistic understanding.

Key findings conclude that while the study found some similarities, there were more differences when comparing AA co-ethnic communities, ethnic social capital, and educational outcomes. Overall, patterns revealed that lower-achieving AA subgroups tend to have weaker communities with fewer resources and opportunities in general. Higher-achieving AA subgroups have stronger co-ethnic networks with more resources and opportunities. The paper details what types of resources and what aspects of co-ethnic networks have helped the higher-achieving AA groups succeed educationally. This information is important because it helps families, educators, and policy makers understand how immigration circumstances affect group educational outcomes and what support various stakeholders can provide to ease immigrant adjustment experiences and eventually improve group outcomes.

Authors