Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Global challenges have forced higher education institutions (HEIs) around the world to improve their quality through tremendous efforts in all sectors for its future sustainability. In Indonesian higher education institutions context, particularly in the Islamic Higher Education Institutions (IHEIs), some institutions have also made great efforts to improve their qualities through institutional transformation. Since the 2000s, under the supervision of the Ministry of Religious Affairs (MORA), many IHEIs have struggled to achieve the institutional transformation which means transforming from a college into an institute, or from an institute to a university. The ultimate goals of this institutional transformation were based on the efforts of Indonesian Intellectual Muslims to modernize the IHEIs system through 1) integrating and modernizing the Islamic religious sciences and secular (general) sciences, 2) playing a greater role in the society both as an ‘objects’ and a ‘subject’ of national development, and 3) improving the number of students admitted to the Islamic Higher Education Institutions (Azra, 2011).
However, after 15 years, the impact of the implementation of institutional transformation on the IHEIs quality is still debatable. There are only 3 of 8 ‘transformed” Islamic Universities which have successfully achieved accreditation A (the highest level of national accreditation), while others still remain below quality (BAN-PT Ristekdikti, 2017). Therefore, to investigate the gap among Islamic Universities, it is important to explore the experiences of leaders who have been the crucial part of this process. The success of the institutional transformation cannot be separated from the roles of leadership. It is undeniable that leaders have crucial roles for the quality improvement and sustainability of their institutions in the future. Based on the literature reviews, some studies have more investigated the IHEIs institutional transformation from sociocultural and historical development aspects (Kinoshita, 2009; Azra, 2011; Lukens-Bull, 2013), however, only a few studies have examined specifically the leadership roles and experiences in the institutional transformation process, particularly from the government and academic leaders perspectives.
Therefore, based on the facts above, this study aims to investigate the roles and experiences of government leaders (MORA) and academic leaders (Islamic University) to understand how these leaders were able (or not) to assist their institutions during the transformation process. This study examines two types of leaders: 1) personality driven leaders, are individuals who are passionate, hard-working, and competitive within their own organization (Larson, 2012) and have a strong influence on the success of such ventures within the structures of university organizations (Denman, 2013); and 2) transformational leaders, the leaders who stimulate and inspire followers to achieve extraordinary outcomes and, in the process, develop their own leadership capacity (Bass & Riggio, 2006), It also seeks the existence and influence of both types within the experiences of government and academic leaders during their involvements in the institutional transformation process.
This study employs a qualitative methodology (e.g. interviews, document collection, reflective memos, and visual images) to capture the specific dimensions of the experiences of leaders. Through qualitative study, this study has used in-depth semi structure-interview which focuses on the exploration of individual leaders’ experiences in the institutional transformation by identifying their experiences (in terms of perceptions and actions) as a leader during the transformation process. This study includes academic leaders (leaders from Islamic University) and leaders from stakeholder institutions (leaders in MORA, administrative offices, ad-hoc committees, lecturer associations, and student associations) who have been involved in the process and the implementation of the institutional transformation. This study explores their perspectives, how the transformation took place, the roles they played, and what their experiences were during these processes. In this study, visual images (e.g. pictures, photos, or artifacts) have been also involved as a metaphor to facilitate the process of data collection to obtain other specific information. The images have been used to communicate more holistically, incorporating multiple layers, and evoking stories or questions (Weber, 2008). Further, the visual images have been used as sources to develop general questions, to obtain detailed views of participants, and to explore the personal strengths and concerns of the participant in giving meanings of the institutional transformation.
The initial study found the existence of both personality-driven and transformational leaders which have played crucial roles for the successfulness of the institutional transformation. The study shows that government leaders and academic leaders have interrelated roles in contributing to the success of institutional transformation which has a crucial impact on the quality improvement of IHEIs and its sustainability in the future. The study shows that academic leaders have played important roles as transformative leaders in assisting the institution through innovative actions in achieving the goals of policies in order to bring about proper implementation for the sustained institution. Meanwhile, the government leaders have also played important tasks in improving the quality of education through policy design and implementation. As leader representatives, both government and academic leaders have an awareness to support the institutional transformation process and played effective strategies for achieving the goals and missions of the institutional transformation policy.
In Indonesia’s IHEIs context, the importance to explore the leadership roles is to understand how the commitment, integrity, and ability to embrace all of the elements required in transformation are manifested among government and academic leaders in the HEIs to respond to the policy issues so that institutions can be transformed, developed and sustained. It is crucial to explore how leaders set the goals for achieving the institution’s mission towards transformation. This study reveals the examples of 1) how particular mission guides an institution in becoming unique; 2) how strong leadership qualities help to guide work and role models for other HEIs.
The results of this study are expected 1) contributes a new knowledge to the general research literature related to policy and leadership in the HE institutional transformation context; 2) provides new leadership models that can inspire other IHEIs’ leaders in achieving the institutional transformation; and 3) advocates policymakers, educators, government and academic leaders, and practitioners in improving the quality of leadership performance for the existence and sustainability of higher education institutions in the future. Furthermore, in terms of research methodology, qualitative research in the study of the leadership captures the subjective experiences of leaders and followers, its slippery nature, and the local context in which leadership takes places (Klenke, 2016). Therefore, for the future research, the study of leadership experiences in institutional transformation policy in Indonesia’s IHEIs context provides the new insights to other researchers about the merits of conducting qualitative research to reveal contextualized and detailed understandings about institutional transformation in a field that has typically relied on quantitative research.