Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
In this paper we draw on interviews conducted with Japanese preschool teachers and directors to explicate how they seek to achieve inclusivity with students and colleagues through an emphasis on collectivity.
When we speak of “inclusive social development,” what is the implied unit of analysis?
From a Western/Anglophone point of view the notion of “inclusive education” begins with the implicit assumptions that children in a class are individuals with diverse needs and abilities, and that teachers respond to these diverse needs and abilities of their students by employing strategies such as “differentiation of instruction” and “creating an atmosphere of respect for difference.” Such strategies reflect an emphasis on valuing inclusion and collectivity, yet they are still centered on notions of individual actors. Japanese philosophical, psychological, and educational points of view would see this as a sort of attribution error. We suggest that a more Japanese way of conceptualizing inclusive education would be to begin with the assumption that classrooms (unless something goes wrong and they become dysfunctional) are inherently inclusive because people (including children) are inherently social and collective.
The psychoanalyst Bin Kimura (1972) introduced the concept of hito to hito no aida (“between one person and another” or “among people”), which suggests that personhood in Japan takes place not inside individuals but rather in the space between them. Hamaguchi Esyun (1988) presented a similar notion of personhood with the concept of kanjin shugi (contextualism), that is, the idea of defining personhood in the context of others. Jibun, the Japanese word for “self,” is also inherently relational, as it carries a meaning of “my portion (of my relationships with others).” Anthropological studies of early childhood education have shown that Japanese teachers give more emphasis to the development of their students as a collective than as individuals (Lewis, 1989: Tsuchida & Lewis, 2011). As we wrote in Teaching Embodied (Hayashi & Tobin, 2015):
Japanese early childhood educators’ discussions of social mindedness differ from most Western conceptions of social-emotional development by viewing children’s capacity to handle disputes and other social interactions more as a function of the class as a community than of each child as an individual. (p.13).
The research method for this study is diachronic video-cued multivocal ethnography (Tobin et al. 1989; Hayashi & Tobin 2015). We conducted video-cued focus-group interviews with 27 experienced Japanese preschool teachers and six preschool directors in which we used as an interviewing stimulus videos of made of typical days in Japanese preschool classrooms.
We draw on these interviews to suggest to ways in which Japanese preschools are collective and inclusive. The first, as the quote above suggests, is that the emphasis of teachers is on scaffolding the growth more of the class as a whole than of individual children. Another dimension of Japanese preschool’s collectivity is in the way Japanese preschool teachers perceive their expertise less as an individual trait than as inseparable from their connection to their colleagues and the school.