Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Policy borrowing and lending in education: the media discourse on PISA and school reform in China

Wed, April 17, 3:15 to 4:45pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Bay (Level 1), Bayview A/B Foyers

Proposal

Historically, since the emergence of national education systems in the nineteenth century, "policy borrowing and lending" from foreign contexts forms an integral part of the development of the modern education systems in all nations (Waldow 2014). With the widespread dissemination of international large-scale assessments in the age of globalization, the patterns of “policy borrowing and lending” in education have acquired new dynamics (Waldow 2017). As the most influential international large-scale assessment, PISA plays an essential role in initiating this change (Steiner-Khamsi 2014).
With the triennially publishing of PISA’s league tables, some top-performing nations and regions have been constructed as the “global model” of education reform, such as Finland. However, other participating societies, which have achieved results on a similar level or scored even higher than Finland in PISA, haven’t been able to gain a similar degree of international acclaim, including Shanghai (Takayama, Waldow, and Sung 2013). The nation’s PISA success alone does not explain the referential status that it currently enjoys on a global scale, as well as in the single countries. For example, in Germany, Finland is constructed as a “positive reference” society, while Asian societies such as Shanghai are considered as “negative reference” societies (Waldow 2014, 2016, 2017).
In 2009, Shanghai participated in PISA for the first time and was immediately ranked first in all three of PISA’s literacy domains (reading, mathematical and scientific literacy), which led to an alternative "PISA-Schock" in the Chinese media (compared to “PISA-Schock” in Germany in 2001, see Waldow 2009). With the varying results of China on the PISA’s league tables in 2012 and 2015, plenty of reflections and discussions on China's education reform was triggered, during which references to other societies have always been made. In this context, the questions arise: Which reference societies and which aspects of the respective reference societies are perceived in the media discourse within China? How are the referential roles of these societies in the school reform constructed in the Chinese media discourse? Which factors contribute to the construction of these societies’ different referential roles?
Numerous studies show that the mass media play an essential role in the political agenda setting through their selection of news to report and the way to present these topics (McCombs & Shaw 1974, Gamson & Modigliani 1989). Mass media therefore serves to reflect on one hand, and produce public policies and opinions on the other hand (Saraisky 2016). In order to answer the above questions, this study selected People's Daily, China Education News and Wenhui Daily as respective representatives of party media, professional newspapers and local newspapers, to analyze media coverage on reference societies in school reform debate of China. The frame analysis is implemented as the primary methodological approach to construct the reference system of Chinese media discourse on school reform. With the help of MAXQDA, a “Map of Reference Societies” will visualize the core conclusions of the analysis and interpretation.

Author