Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Since the 1990s, expressions such as 'weak states', 'failed states', 'quasi-states' and other variations have been used in aid practitioners' discourses and scholarly works to describe a range of states and their problems (Grimm, Lemay-Hebert & Nay, 2014). International actors such as the American Fund for Peace has developed a league table, the Fragile States index to rank states based on their degree of state vulnerability, while the OECD publishes the States of Fragility report annually since 2005 to inform and guide donor policies. The targets of these labels and donor policies are clear: post-colonial states lacking the institutional qualities of the Weberian state, which derives its legitimacy from rational-legal authority and holds monopoly over violence.
Myanmar, a former British colony in Southeast Asia that features in nearly every fragile state index has been chosen to provide a lens through which to examine the political, economic and socio-cultural factors that influence everyday citizenship in conflict-affected postcolonial states. Myanmar is a multi-ethnic state that is currently experimenting with economic liberalisation, disciplined-democracy and peacebuilding after years of civil wars, communist uprisings and military rule since its independence in 1948. The ‘state’ in Myanmar is merely one actor among others and the state order is only one of a number of orders claiming to provide security, frameworks for conflict regulation and public goods (Taylor, 2009). Further, customary Buddhist practices continue to empower the imagination of Myanmar’s political futures and permeates Bamar society till today (Schober, 2011). Therefore, Myanmar is not a ‘modern’, secular state in the Weberian sense.
How then, can we bring the state back in to understand education-mediated social relations in contemporary postcolonial, conflict-affected contexts? What are the analytical alternatives? Located within the postcolonial paradigm, this paper rejects the Westphalian approach to security and development and explores the theoretical fruitfulness of two alternative conceptualisations of postcolonial, conflict-affected states: Volker Boege, M. Anne Brown and Kevin P. Clements’ concept of hybrid political order and Bob Jessop’s Strategic Relational Approach. The concept of hybridity has occupied a central place in postcolonial discourse since Bhabha’s development of the concept to describe the construction of culture and identity within conditions of antagonism and inequity. On the other hand, the strategic relational approach to the state is rooted in Marxist traditions and Marx has been criticised by many postcolonial theorists as a Eurocentric or even Orientalist thinker.
However, in this presentation, I argue that the strategic relational approach provides a more fruitful theoretical lens to understand youth citizenship in contemporary postcolonial, conflict-affected contexts. I demonstrate the theoretical fruitfulness of SRA and the limitations of the concept of hybrid political order by applying the two concepts to examine the same data collected from semi-structured interviews and photo-elicitation techniques during 5 months of fieldwork in two different cities in Myanmar.