Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Nations and numbers. The banal nationalism of large-scale assessments.

Mon, April 15, 8:00 to 9:30am, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Atrium (Level 2), Boardroom C

Proposal

This exploratory paper is focused on the question of how to understand the escalating avalanche of education performance data, particularly the expansion of national and international large-scale assessments of learning outcomes. We seek to complement recent discussions on the topic by developing a theoretically driven perspective, and illustrating it with examples from our and others’ research. We argue that nationalism, and the continuous processes of nation-building, have played and continue to play a strong role in the governance of states, education systems and institutions. Researchers have widely acknowledged the fact that performance data in general and large-scale assessment of education in particular have turned into the modern Oracle of educational truth (Gorur, 2017). However, surprisingly little attention has been paid to how the Oracle converses in the patriotic language of homogenous nations, cultures and peoples, manifesting continuities between the present and the entangled histories of statistics, nationalism and education. The perspective of nationalism has been peripheral in the literature on education governance by data, and studies concerned with the contemporary rise of assessment data have so far predominantly related the phenomena to Europeanization (Lawn & Grek, 2012), globalization (Rizvi & Lingard, 2010) and neoliberalism (Ball, 2003). Even when the phenomena are related to the re-centralization of the state, for instance, the discussions do not extend to the issue of how new assessments perform the nation, too.
By nationalism, we refer to the ideology, discourses and practices that assert that the nation and the state correspond (Gellner, 1983), turning the nation, defined in cultural and linguistic terms, into the main source of political legitimation of a defined territory. Nationalism is also an international model that perceives the world as meticulously divided into mutually exclusive sovereign national units that function precisely because they have developed powerful strategies that reproduce the nations as nations. Following a constructivist understanding of nations as imagined (which nevertheless does not make them any less “real”; Anderson, 1983), we see nations as relying on carefully planned, but also mundane/hidden, long-term nation-building policies and practices, adopted to diffuse and strengthen a sense of nationhood. Nation-building is a continuous process through which a dominant culture tends to become a hegemonic culture of conversion and assimilation, triggering a process of “internal colonizing” of a territory (Hechter, 1975), claiming a universalistic effect within the territory of the state (Zambeta, 2005), powerful enough to transform (seemingly?) international endeavors and data into national(ist) programs of cultural reproduction, ironically legitimated by its international performance.
As Billig (1995) has argued, nationalism is often mistakenly understood for an extreme and exotic force, thus relegating it to the periphery of unstable political formations and ignoring the daily reproduction of nationhood in established nations. We take Billig’s seminal book on the banal reproduction of nationalism as our starting point for two reasons. First, we want to align our work with Billig’s argument that the diagnosis of globalization scholars that nationalism is a fading condition – is false. Thus follows the imperative to scrutinize the reproduction of nationalistic sentiments in multiple everyday contexts – and education has historically been one of the prime sites of nationalistic socialization, but also contestation. Second, the term is a reminder of our own, that is – scholars’ – banal embeddedness in methodological nationalism. Is nationalism too familiar to be noticed, or taken seriously as an object of intellectual scrutiny, we thus ask?
This paper makes a case in favour of viewing the rise of assessment data through the analytical lenses of nationalism and nation-building. We explore how data on performance perform the world into being in nationalistically colored ways, constructing domains and rendering them stable for further calculation, deliberation and ordering (Popkewitz, 2012). This happens through, for instance, the decisions and practices of who is measured, how and for what purpose, as well as by putting data to nationalistic political uses and affirming its value through largely normalized nationalistic rhetoric. We aim to show that education data contributes to the ongoing reproduction of national boundaries and performs nations into being. At the same time, the national imaginary and the unquestioned preeminence of nation-states power the very rise of education data. Education data enable the routine “flagging” of the nation, and we are interested in the practices and politics of education data that sustain nationalism as ‘an endemic condition’ of the world.

Authors