Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Another Dimension of ‘Concerted Cultivation’ and Its Global Application: Student Participation in Private Supplementary Education in 63 Societies

Wed, April 17, 3:15 to 4:45pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific B

Proposal

Scholars in the United States have found differential participation of students in non-academic extracurricular activities, such as sports and music, by family background. A cultural explanation, represented by the concept of ‘concerted cultivation’, emphasizes a cultural mode of parenting among middle class parents, distinctive from the cultural mode of ‘natural growth’ among working class parents. In this paper, we extend this literature in two important ways.
First, we suggest that the conception of concerted cultivation can be applied to student participation in various forms of academically-oriented private supplementary education after regular school hours. The intensified competition for children’s educational success in many contemporary societies, combined with rising income inequality and growing economic return to educational credentials, has pushed parents, particularly of middle class, to invest more in children’s education. This, in turn, has increased demand for organized learning opportunities to students after formal schooling. Moreover, student participation in private supplementary education is not only affected by family economic resources but actually requires parents’ concerted efforts to find the ‘right’ private tutors and learning centers, to schedule students’ after-school hours, and to communicate with private instructors for their children’s progress. The organized nature of activities and required parental involvement make private supplementary education an arena for concerted cultivation.
Second, we argue that student participation in private supplementary education as concerted cultivation is not limited to a specific region but is actually global. We empirically show how mother’s education, which indicates cultural logic of parenting, is significantly associated with student participation in private supplementary education, even after taking into account family economic resources, in most countries among 63 countries that participated in the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA).
We draw on data of 15-year-old students from PISA 2012. In particular, PISA 2012 specifically asked students to indicate whether they “attend out of school classes organized by a commercial company, and paid for by parents.” We use this information to create our dichotomous outcome variable of whether students participated in a private supplementary education activity.
We distinguish students into four different groups depending on their mother’s educational attainment: those whose mothers have (1) less than high school education, (2) high school, (3) some college education (but not a bachelor’s degree), and (4) a bachelor’s degree. In order to interpret the effect of mother’s education to reflect cultural orientation, it is critical to control for an extensive list of family economic resources which tend to be correlated with mother’s education.
First, our descriptive analysis shows that in 53 societies, at least 10 or higher percentages of students take part in academically focused out-of-school activities, which reflects the global scale of private supplementary education. Then, our logistic regression analysis for each country shows that in 43 societies, students whose mothers have a bachelor’s degree are significantly more likely to attend out of school classes than their counterparts whose mothers have less than high school education. In other words, the result reveals the global scale of concerted cultivation for student participation in private supplementary education.

Authors