Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Problem solving and problem types: going beyond real life issues

Thu, April 18, 8:00 to 9:30am, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Bay (Level 1), Bayview B

Proposal

It is crucial that teachers embrace their role supporting and guiding children finding their voice as they grow to be critical global citizens through the use of mathematics. Using problems to teach mathematics is regarded by teachers and educators as a successful. But the type of problems used by teachers also plays a role. In times where the disenchantment with political leaders is clear by the reduced numbers of voters (United States and Brazil past elections), it is never too early to start educating critical citizens. Teachers need to use all of the tools they have, including mathematics. Culturally relevant mathematics (CRM), and teaching math for social justice (M4SJ) are weapons teacher have to do just that. In this proposal the authors exposed pre-service teachers in the US and Uruguay to different problem types, including M4SJ and culturally relevant ones, and asked them which ones they preferred and they did not prefer to use to teach mathematics. Then they were asked why they made those choices. The authors expect not only to learn what are walls or entry ways to teach CRM and M4SJ, but to take from one geographical setting and be able to apply to the other.

As critical global citizens, children need to develop an awareness and skill to go beyond being complacent with globalization, corporatization, and materialization. With this civic competence the students then pursue their own and other fellow citizen's happiness, even if this means a struggle, which they will be prepared to face. And hat happiness will not just be their own, but everyone's happiness, because "… anyone's injustice is everyone's injustice" (Parker, 2003, p. 8), and how closely connected their lives with other citizens' lives are, when at the same time being highly engaged in the public life. They will clearly know that the fight against injustice is a fight for happiness, and the students as critical global citizens are ready to fight that battle. But how can teachers do this while teaching mathematics?

Teaching M4SJ and CRM is what the authors of this proposal believe to be the most important tool teachers can count on today. Mathematics, and social justice pedagogical goals are central to teaching mathematics in such a way children see not only the power of math, but also their own power and voice. These goals, according to Gutstein (2006), are: reading the mathematical world, succeeding academically in the traditional sense, and changing one's orientation to mathematics; reading the world with mathematics, writing the world with mathematics, and developing positive cultural and social identities. Also teaching M4SJ means teaching math through problem solving, which is one of the recommendations of the National Council of Teachers or Mathematics (NCTM) in the US. But what kind of contexts do pre-service teachers lean to when they choose problems to teach math? Do they lean towards MfSJ, or simply problems that present the children with real world connections?

Using the framework developed by Simic-Muller, Fernandez and Felton-Koestler (2015), the authors of this proposal offered pre-service teachers in the US and Uruguay mathematics story problems, and asked them to pick which problems they would use and not use, and to explain why. In the framework mentioned above, the four categories of problems are: real world situations, controversial issues, issues of injustice, and family backgrounds or community practice. Knowing what categories pre-service teachers lean to and why, will help teacher educators to tailor their lessons to bridge those preferences and the practice of teaching M4SJ. Having groups of students from different countries will also help, depending on their similarities and differences, what can math teacher educators do and avoid to help pre-service teachers approach M4SJ.

The problems were not simply translated, but similar problems were created for each pre-service teacher groups depending on their country of origin. For example, for category “issues of injustice”, in Uruguay pre-service teachers were shown the problem “En lo que va del 2018, 124 mujeres denunciaron a su pareja o ex-pareja por violencia de género. Diez de ellas consiguieron una orden de restriccion en contra del agresor. En otros 5 cases las parejas o ex-parejas fueron deteninas por 48 horas. Y en el resto de los casos no hubo consecuencias para los agresores. ¿En cuántos de estos casos no hubo consecuencias para los agresores?” The corresponding problem that US pre-service teachers were shown was “One hundred and three children under the age of 5 were separated from their parents under the ‘zero tolerance’ policy. The number of children who were reunited with their parents (by July 19th) was 57. How many children under the age of 5 remain separated from their parents?” Some of the problems were offered in both settings, like for category “controversial issues, where climate change was one of the topics chosen. Also, the authors of this proposal created and vetted problems. They shared the problems with other teacher preparation instructors in each country to check on the relevance of each story for the corresponding context.

Pre-service teachers are currently completing the survey, and descriptive statistics will be calculated and analyzed by the authors. They will also use discourse analysis and grounded theory to study the short response answers the pre-service teachers offered while explaining their choices. Themes for each geographical setting will be uncovered and compared for each, and themes across the two settings will also be taken into consideration. The qualitative data will be coded to facilitate the search for proving and disproving evidence for each of those themes.

Data collection is happening during Fall 2018, and analysis and preparation of results and presentation will happen January through February 2019. During March and April the paper will be completed. The study is not only relevant to comparative and international education by nature, but also to the Special Interest Group (SIG) Global Mathematics Education. It proposes to compare different geographical contexts, while also learning from one to apply to the other.

Authors