Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
“Human beings, and learners, exist in a cultural context.”
Paulo Freire (1970/1995)
Within the NGO and scholarly communities focused on education initiatives in Tanzania, there is an appeal for descriptive information that could help NGOs conceptualize more applicable initiatives for young children in Tanzania.
This interdisciplinary and transnational research responds to this appeal and presents a focused ethnography of a local context of teaching and learning in rural southern Tanzania addressing issues of Indigenous knowledges and decolonial perspectives in the Ndogo village and surrounding area. The purpose of this study is to provide voice and agency to the local context of multiple opportunities to learn for young children in the home, the community, and the school.
Theoretical framework
Due to the history of the country of Tanzania and the global movement of people, ideas, and technology there are a number of potential ideologies at play in the village of Ndogo. The intersections of national and global influences are complicated and converge on many levels. Using sociocultural theory (Gonzalez, Moll, & Amanti, 2005; Borko & Putnam, 1998), this paper explores a detailed description of the contexts and opportunities for children to learn in the village of Ndogo.
This study outlines the practices of the Ndogo community and school and compares the local perceptions to the internationally accepted framework of DIP/DAP. The study examins the framework of the context-dependent approaches alongside a framework of the dominant and standardized approaches to learn. To look through each framework demonstrates how they influence the opportunities young children have to learn. The context-dependent approaches were gleaned from observations and interviews in Ndogo regarding the Ndogo culturally appropriate and inappropriate practices for young children. The approaches of the dominant and standardized appropriate and inappropriate practices for young children are found in early childhood education literature over the past thirty years.
Transnational research and literature, and mainstream global child development concepts and perspectives, such as Developmentally (In)Appropriate Practices (DAP/DIP), influenced Tanzanian national government in the policy creation process. An early childhood scholar in Tanzania related to me that his framework of decision-making in the classroom and his interpretation of children and parent behaviors were filtered through the Developmentally (In)Appropriate Practices (DAP/DIP) framework (Bredekamp, 1986). The majority of early childhood educators use this framework because it has been considered the gold standard for early childhood education in the United States (Van Horn, Karlin, & Ramey, 2012).
In opposition to the concepts perpetuated in the dominate early childhood discourse such as developmentally inappropriate practice (DIP) and developmentally appropriate practice (DAP), it is argued that there are not clear cut binary “appropriate” and “inappropriate” cultural practices. Ways of conceptualizing what young children have the opportunity to learn about in a particular context are presented including indigenous knowledge.
Data collection and analysis
The sources of information in this study are the Ndogo people of the Ndogo village. Data was collected from 159 participants through semi-structured interviews, observations, and focus groups conducted with students, teachers, parents, and village members. Influences from outside the community including from the national government and international donor organizations are also included.
Grounded theory was used to systematically describe the context of young children and their opportunities to learn. A bottom-up approach was used to code the information from the interviews and allowed what was observed to devise a frame of the findings (Glaser & Strauss, 2009).
The analysis of the data is also informed by the sources of information. This is a descriptive study and I retell what I heard other people say about their experiences and share what I saw. Due to the limitations of my study, I was not able to capture their practices but only to observe them. Britzman (2000) expressed how participants in a study “may well be the tellers of the experience; but every telling is constrained, partial, and determined by the discourses and histories that prefigure, even as they might promise, representation” (p. 32). Given this caveat, I focused my attention on personal stories, observations, and descriptions while steering away from mass generalizations or characterizations.
Significance
Notions about what is conceptualized as quality early childhood education vary according to context. Pence and Nsamenang (2008) reiterated the need for the “Minority World to help the Majority World in its quest for child well-being, by supporting Africa’s efforts to hear its own voices and seek its own way forward” (p. v). Limited systematic efforts were made to understand what opportunities exist for young children to learn in rural Tanzania. This study adds to the literature that addresses the nuances, ambiguities, and complexities of the opportunities for young children to learn in and out of formal school in a specific context. Sally Lubeck (1998) observed that “we do not currently have many ways to think about such things, to observe alternative ways, or engage in unfamiliar activities that might challenge our views of what children - and teachers - can do” (p. 5).
Soto and Swadener (2005), scholars dedicated to creating a stutter in conversations about early childhood education, articulated that “It is clear that it will be crucial for the field to continue to critically analyze how privilege and power have influenced the direction of the field toward the scientifically driven epistemologies and valorized the rationalistic Western lens. Who stands to benefit from the overreliance on Western ways of seeing the world?” (p. 55-56). Soto and Swadener along with other early childhood scholars advocated for studies to examine the context of young children’s opportunities to learn such as this one.
Along with Dahlberg, Moss, and Pence (1999), this study is “not arguing, however, for the replacement of one dominating language (about early childhood education) with another” (p. 2). Rather, I aspire to introduce a hesitation into the dominant conversation about visions for young children’s education. This study was designed to provide a nuance and complex description of young children’s opportunities to learn in a particular location. The notions of what is “appropriate” and “inappropriate” for young children to learn is not universal. There is a call in Tanzania for NGO’s and government initiatives for young children to be informed by the examination of young children in complex and nuanced ways. In rural southern Tanzania more attention could be given to the diversity of early childhood education practices within the sociocultural context. Educating young children is contextualized; it is not universal.