Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Providing justice in classrooms: A snapshot of refugee education in Turkey, Jordan and Lebanon

Mon, April 15, 1:30 to 3:00pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific C

Proposal

Providing Justice in Classroom: A Snapshot of Refugee Education in Turkey, Jordan and Lebanon
Proposal for CIES 2019 San Francisco April 14-18, 2019
Education for Sustainability
In recent years, war, poverty, terror and other factors forced 68,500,000 people to leave their countries (UNCHR, 2018), and hosting countries are faced with several problems. As one way to decrease the effects of these problems, most host countries give privileged importance to education of refugees (Toker Gokce & Acar, 2018). Turkey, has host the biggest refugee population proportionally, particularly after the Syrian civil war in 2011 (UNCHR, 2015), and has mandated the education of refugee students by law in September 2014(Circular Letter No: 2014/21). Furthermore, this is the first time that Ministry of National Education in Turkey has included the plans for refugees' education in its strategic plan for 2015-2019 (Emin, February, 2016, p.8). These policies are aimed to guarantee the education of refugees without residence permits to place within various education institutions by such as temporary training centers, public schools, private schools opened by Syrians, vocational courses and projects, orphanages and higher education institutions (Toker Gokce & Acar, 2018; Duruel, 2016). However, these policies have not yet reached the aimed achievements as much as planned because of the unsystematic approaches in their implementation (Beltekin, 2016). Since hosting a significant amount of refugees is new phenomena for Turkey, a comparison and sharing of experiences with other hosting countries has the possibility of improving the planned strategies on refugee education. As Ficarra explained (2017) "Refugee education is a global process and as such educating teachers abroad their current or future refugee students should draw on lessons from around the world. .... With the eyes of the world currently on the global Syrian refugee crisis, this is a moment to be seized by educators globally to work together, to better the educational experiences and outcomes of refugee and immigrant students across national contexts" (p. 83). However, there is limited comparative research that have been conducted about this issue (Ficarra, 2017). The countries that are recently faced with a refugee education crisis can be inspired by the experiences of other countries, which have been handling similar problems in similar regions. In terms of refugee education problem, Turkey suffers the same fate with Lebanon and Jordan (976,002 and 671,919 Syrian refugees respectively) (UNCHR, 2018). Therefore, a comparative examination of these three countries might be helpful to uncover different perspective to various problems in refugee education.
This study is framed by Equity Theory (Adams, 1963), and Justice Theory (Rawls, 1999) of education that is connected to the UN Sustainable Development Goals 4 (2018) which is "Ensure inclusive and equitable quality education and promote lifelong learning opportunities for all" and the education sustainability all around the world, aligning with the CIES conference theme. The purpose of this qualitative study is to synthesize the experiences of the teachers from three different countries (Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan) in terms of fair assessment of students in mixed schools (refugees and natives). Synthesizing teacher experiences might give a deeper understanding to equity problems of refugee children in Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan.
In this study, twelve middle school teachers (4 Turks, 4 Jordanians, 4 Lebaneses) are interviewed to share the experiences and the challenges they face with-in mixed classroom environments in particular and with refugee education in general.
This empirical research is guided by these questions:
- How do the teachers provide equality between the refugees and native students in mixed classes when they are assessing the tests, homework and in class activities?
-How can positive discrimination be applied in classroom environment to provide justice, and what can the results of positive discrimination for a specific group in classroom?
-What are the alternatives of current assessment system for mixed classes?
To get the answers for these questions, semi-standardized one-on-one interviews are conducted. These interviews are analyzed by data reduction, data display and verification methods. Preliminary findings show that teachers commonly struggle with providing justice during the assessment process (exams, homework, grading in-class activities) between refugees and natives. This study will contribute to the literature, which is limited in comparative research about justice problems in assessments of refugee students in Western Asia. Since many countries are still suffering from refugee education issue, the first-hand experiences and recommendations shared by the teachers in these countries can be inspirational for policy-makers who continue to seek for solutions to enhance justice in education.

Author