Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Role of Local Community Involvement—School Management Shuras— in Supporting Girls’ Education in Afghanistan

Thu, April 18, 1:30 to 3:00pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific K

Proposal

Abstract
Community involvement is a key success factor to support girls’ education in many developing countries, including Afghanistan. As a result, Afghan Government and its international development partners established School Management Shuras—Council— (SMS) for all schools throughout the country. SMSs are made of volunteer local community members. Some research and official reports discuss SMSs as a sub topic. They report on SMSs’ significant role in girls’ education. Yet, little research has been done to investigate the function of these shuras as a main topic. Therefore, some is known about the success and failure of these shuras and their impact on girls’ education; however, this knowledge is not enough to explain how the majority of SMSs function and what the key factors are that make either a successful or an unsuccessful shura. For that reason, we reviewed the existing sporadic literature, public reports and related policies to understand the function of these shuras and their key success and failure factors. The product is a unit piece that explains the role of these shuras at several levels and indicates areas that need further research. This piece is an initial step for a prospective qualitative study.

Objectives:
Many governments, as well as international development agencies, in the last two decades, have emphasized the importance of local community involvement in the implementation of developmental projects. Girls’ education is one of these projects (Karlsson & Mansory, 2007; Burde & Linden, 2013; Adkins, 2016, Sehin et al., 2017, Jamal, 2014). Despite considerable efforts, girls’ education is still a major problem that the Ministry of Education (MoE) and its partners face in Afghanistan (National Education Strategic Plan III, 2017). For example, a 2012 Tokyo conference highlighted concerns that access to education was still a challenge for boys and girls in rural and urban areas of Afghanistan and that the “future of Afghan girls’ education remained largely uncertain” (Sameul Hall, 2014, p.5). Community mobilization and involvement has been considered a solution to tackle this problem (Jamal, 2014). As a result, Afghan government and its international partners recognized that in order to increase girls’ enrollment rates and decrease their school dropout rates, having the support of local communities is an important phenomenon (National Education Strategic Plan III, 2017).
Therefore, a School Management Shura—Council—(SMS) was established for each public school in the country. SMSs, which are made of volunteer local community members, were tasked with an agenda on how to help education in Afghanistan. Girls’ education was at the top of the list (Social Mobilization Strategy, 2017). Research and official reports, while focusing on other topics, indirectly convey numerous sporadic stories of the success and failure of these shuras (Sameul Hall, 2014). Few studies, however, focus on SMSs as main topic. Even though SMSs were established in 2008, many of them are still not active or successful. Policies on SMSs have been reviewed and re-written several times. Unfortunately, these reviews do not seem to be very effective. The problem is that there is little research on SMSs to help future policies in the betterment of SMSs’ function. Reviewing policies will not be effective until there is enough knowledge and research on achievement, failure, functioning, and the problems of SMSs. Therefore, by reviewing the existing literature, we tried to take an initial step towards such research. In other words, this study is a start to reach an understanding on how active engagement of local communities can help improve girls’ education in the context of Afghanistan, and how active engagement of local communities in Afghanistan’s context can be increased. In more specific terms; we tried to put together the broken pieces of knowledge around SMSs that so far exist.

Methods, Data, and Analysis:
This is a literature review that is designed to serve as a part of a bigger prospective qualitative study on SMSs in Afghanistan. The literature used for this piece includes independent and organizational research, official documents and reports, other public reports, as well as MoE’s Database (Education Management Information System).

Results:
The product of this study is a unit that brought together sporadic findings and understandings around SMSs. Our analysis of the literature indicates that first, not all SMSs that are registered with the MoE function in the real world. Second, active and successful SMSs have a positive impact on girls’ education. Third, SMSs who received training and are aware of their work agenda have a tangible impact on girls’ education. Fourth, women get less chance to participate in SMSs’ activities. Fifth, whenever women get a chance to participate, they improve SMSs’ impact considerably. Sixth, there are many duplicate initiatives surrounding SMSs between MoE and its other partners. Seventh, major parts of MoE’s policies and strategies on SMSs remain unpracticed.

Contribution
This study may contribute to research and governmental policies in several ways. First, this study introduces a unit piece that gathers all the literature related to SMSs. Second, by indicating the knowledge gap in the area, it paves the way for future research. Third, it may help future policy makers in developing realistic and more practicable policies and strategies for local community involvement for girls’ education in general and SMSs in particular. Fourth, and at an ambitious and broad level, it may help improve girls’ education in Afghanistan.

Author