Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

International Students’ Participation Patterns in Learning Communities in Higher Education: A Comparative Analysis Between National Trends and Indiana University Bloomington

Mon, April 15, 10:00 to 11:30am, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific O

Proposal

Over the last few decades, as the diversity of the United States has increased, higher education institutions have been faced with the problem of international students’ academic engagement and success. Although prior studies have explored the educational experiences of international students in the United States, only few of them have investigated international students’ engagement patterns in learning community practices at four-year institutions. Learning communities are considered as one of the ten high-impact practices that Kuh (2008) suggested for higher education institutions to utilize to promote their students’ academic, interpersonal, and extracurricular engagement and success. According to Kuh (2008), institutions that effectively apply learning communities may have the potential to create and maintain an environment that fosters collaboration and commitment to the growth and development of students. The experience may in turn play a significant supportive role in students’ acquisition of deep, integrative learning, critical thinking and writing skills, as well as their appreciation for diversity and sense of belonging to the campus - all important factors for student success (Brownell & Swaner, 2010).

While the potential impacts associated with learning communities make these practices attractive in the eyes of institutions and in the international education platforms globally, a quick analysis of the current body of literature demonstrates that learning communities can be defined differently and may vary in their scale, and thus in their impact on students from one context to another (Otto, Evins, Boyer-Pennington & Brinthaupt, 2015). Highlighting these concerns, Taylor et al. (2003) emphasized that a deep study of learning communities in student populations is required to provide guidance to help target solutions for institutions so students can get the most out of these experiences. To contribute to Taylor’s (2003) efforts as well as moving the needle further on the subject, in this quantitative comparative study, I will use a large-scale, multi institutional survey dataset (the National Survey of Student Engagement) to explore international students’ engagement patterns and experiences in learning communities at both national and institutional levels. Adopted from Chun-Mei and Kuh (2004), the following four questions will lead the study:

1. What is the relationship between participating in a learning community and international students’ engagement in a range of educationally productive activities, including interaction with faculty members, active and collaborative learning, and the extent to which classes emphasize higher-order thinking?
2. To what degree is participation in learning communities associated with differences in international students’ self- reported gains in personal and social development, and general education?
3. How is participation in learning community practices associated with international students’ satisfaction with their campus environments?
4. How does Indiana University Bloomington, an institution with large international student population, measure up with the national trends when it comes to students’ engagement in educationally purposeful activities as well as their self- reported gains in personal and social development, general education, and satisfaction with their campus?

The data for the study is collected from senior level higher-education students including the entire international population (n=5,123) who participated in the National Survey of Student Engagement (NSSE) of 2015. To provide some background information on the survey instrument, NSSE is administered every year to both first and senior-year students across the U.S. institutions to demonstrate student behaviors associated with desired outcomes of college, pointing to areas where institutions are performing well and aspects that could be improved depending on students’ self-reported data (NSSE, 2015). Adopting from Tinto’s (1993) seminal work as well as those of Tierney (1992) and Kuh (1995) on student success, NSSE divides student engagement into four themes around ten indicators. The empirical analysis conducted consider that all the engagement indicators pointed out at NSSE have sufficient validity to contribute to institutional assessment efforts (NSSE 2008). In this presentation, for the sake of brevity, I only report on three engagement indicators, including interaction with faculty members, active and collaborative learning, and the extent to which classes emphasize higher-order thinking. In order to find the relationship between participating in a learning community and international students’ engagement in these three well-supported educationally productive activities/engagement indicators, I will conduct a series of multivariate ordinary least squares regressions. In fact, multivariate least square regressions will be applied to answer the other three questions as well. The students’ demographic characteristics (e.g., gender, major of study, and year of class), as well as the institutional characteristics (e.g., control type and Carnegie classifications) and the academic outcomes for students (e.g., course grades, and the highest level of education that the students expect to obtain) will be controlled for all four questions.

This research offers an invaluable contribution to scholarly conversations in the field of international and comparative education about learning communities. By delving into the details of data at the national level and comparing the trends to those at the institutional level, the focused study sheds a brighter light on the value of learning communities for international students while providing direct and actionable insights into the effectiveness of their practices and implementation at Indiana University Bloomington. While participation in learning communities are linked with such positive behaviors as increased academic effort and outcomes such as promoting openness to diversity, social tolerance, and personal and interpersonal development, such deeper examination of these practices specifically as they relate to international students, an underdeveloped area of inquiry, is warranted to help ensure universities in the United States and beyond are equipped to train and retain this student population.

Author