Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Navigating the aims of education: A comparative study of transnational education and development projects

Tue, April 16, 8:00 to 11:30am, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Bay (Level 1), Seacliff C

Proposal

I am a doctoral candidate at the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education / University of Toronto. My dissertation research titled "Navigating the aims of education: A comparative study of transnational education and development projects” was recently approved by my dissertation committee, supervised by Dr. Rubén Gaztambide-Fernández. At the time of writing this, I have collected data in all sites (Chile, Central African Republic, Canada and Luxembourg), and am in the process of coding and analyzing data in order to write my dissertation chapters.

In this research, I investigate three central questions. First, how do different constituents understand the aims, aspirations, and accomplishments of two educational development projects––one in Chile, with funding from Global Affairs Canada (GAC) and the other in Central African Republic (CAR) with funding from Luxembourg––and in what ways do these understandings reflect, contradict, complement, or compete with each other? Second, how do local communities navigate external development frameworks for education? And third, how can evaluation methodologies involve constituents as co-researchers to implicate the multiple conceptual frameworks and cosmovisions operating in each context? The cases in this study illustrate grassroots communities’ attempts to define education and development according to their own aspirations, and for external constituents to support these efforts while adhering to the priorities of their countries’ education and development frameworks. In both sites, I have been employed as a third-party evaluator for each project, providing opportunities to explore project experiences with local and external constituents. Site A is a project in the Williche Indigenous territories in southern Chile. Site B is a teacher-education organization supporting a network of community schools in five regions of the Central African Republic (CAR).

In exploring the ways that constituents understand the aims and accomplishments of these two projects, I frame education in development theoretically as operating across transnational landscapes that are suffused and informed by the logic of coloniality and modernity (Cusicanqui, 2012; Quijano, 2007; Wynter, 2003; Mignolo, 2009; Walsh, 2012). While pervasive, colonial modernity does not entirely define or dictate the efforts and activities pursued by local actors, who navigate projects and external frameworks as protagonists of their own development. I thus draw on scholars in my theoretical framework who argue that Indigenous and local actors have much to contribute to development and education through self-determination and resilience in navigating external frameworks for education and engaging in reciprocal partnerships (e.g. Abdi, 2011; de Souza Santos 2015; Dei 2008; Escobar, 2011; Farrell 2008; Tuhiwai Smith, 2011). To approach questions of mutually constructive North-South and South-South partnerships theoretically, I take up participation as a relational construct that can serve as a context for intercultural solidarity, provided that the colonial context is grappled with epistemologically and ontologically (e.g. Gaztambide-Fernández, 2011; Maldonado-Torres, 2007; de Souza Santos, 2015).

The methodology of this study involves participatory approaches to program evaluation and ethnographic interviews and focus groups. Participation widens the epistemic scope available to evaluators by questioning where knowledge resides and asserting that people are likely in the best position to address their struggles (Koirala-Azad & Fuentes, 2009). In positioning students, teachers, and staff at the centre of the evaluation process, I take an interpretive posture to learn how stakeholders identify meaningful experiences and changes for themselves and their communities (Alcoff, 2009; Greene, 2000; Stake, 1995). I also strive to consider the tendency to observe a context that is unfamiliar to me “with imperial eyes,” by opening questions about the epistemic and ontological assumptions around notions such as impact, place, and time (Tuhiwai Smith, 1999). After participating in research design and training sessions together, participant researchers collect data through interviews and focus groups that employ creative visual prompts. In addition to participatory data, I will also conduct document analysis of curricular materials, participant observation of educational activities, and interviews about the evaluation process.

Canada and Luxembourg are among the many OECD countries committed to supporting international development, humanitarianism, and peacebuilding, especially through education. Yet, successful and sustainable intercultural work is not easy, requiring continual reflection on the intentions, motivations, and vantage points that drive transnational projects and partnerships. The cases and analysis of this research aim to (a) inform methodological approaches to participatory program evaluation in intercultural settings, including research by and with Indigenous communities; (b) provide insight into how local populations are empowered to take ownership for advancing and sustaining development projects; and (c) inform how educational development projects, policies, and research agendas align and are appropriate to the needs and aspirations of local communities, including Indigenous communities.

Author