Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

A Comparative Analysis of Frameworks for 21st Century Competences in Mainland China and United States: Implications for National Policies

Tue, April 16, 1:30 to 3:00pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Atrium (Level 2), Garden Room A

Proposal

In the new millennium, influenced by factors such as increasing global competition, technological automation and new professional needs, the goals of the global education system have shifted more clearly to the broad skills required in the 21st century knowledge society (Care, Kim, Anderson and Gustafsson-Wright, 2016). These skills or abilities are often referred to as "21 century skills" (P21 2002, ATC21S 2009, C21 2011), "21 century competencies" (NIER 2013, MOE Singapore 2014), "key competencies" (OECD 1999, MOE China 2014), "key competences" (EU 2006) or "transversal competencies", etc. Despite the above-mentioned diverse terminology, in this paper we adhere to the term 21st century competencies. These competencies are generally characterized as being associated with higher-order thinking skills and behaviors that represent the ability to cope with complex problems and unpredictable situations((Voogt and Roblin 2012), which are essential for personal success, social prosperity, and national competitiveness. The 21st century skills movement has emerged in the United States. The American think tanks, Brookings Institution, pointed out that this is a global movement (Care, Kim, Anderson and Gustafsson-Wright 2016). In this movement, the two largest economies in the world, China and United States, introduced their own 21st century competencies frameworks in 2016 and 2002 respectively which were put into practice later. The 21st century competencies framework of the US has exerted great impact on different countries and regions in the world, which becomes a major education reform that China is currently advocating and implementing. It is another national change in China after the implementation of the “new curriculum reform” in 2001 with its focus changing from “three-dimensional goal” to “key competencies”. This study aims to compare these two frameworks and their implementation in the US and China.

The early literatures had compared several 21st century competencies frameworks in the world (Voogt and Roblin 2012, Ananiadou and Claro 2009, Dede 2010, Suto 2013, Kai Wah Chu 2017), but little attention was paid to the frameworks in mainland China. No scholars have specifically compared the 21st century competencies frameworks between China and the US. This study will make a document analysis of these two frameworks by exploring the official website, policy texts, and research literatures.

The following research questions will guide the study: (1) Who proposed the 21st century competencies framework? Which people, organizations or departments are involved in the formulation? (2) Why develop the 21st century competencies framework? What is the socio-economic background, national strategic needs, underlying rationales and purposes? (3) We attempted to clarify the similarities and differences between these two frameworks: What is the structure of these two frameworks? How the 21st century competencies are defined? What are the commonalities and differences regarding their structure, focus and nature? (4) How is the implementation of the 21st century competencies in these two countries? What are the institutional arrangements or policy supports for the implementation? Practice strategies advocated, progression of implementation, the criticisms and challenges encountered, etc. are compared.

The paper concludes that (1) The frameworks of both China and the US had defined "What should be learnt?" However, the focus, intention and practice varied across these two countries: it was a bottom-up reform in US with a focus on social-economic needs, while it was reversely a top-down process in mainland China emphasizing the cultivation of morality. The US framework introduce a sophisticated supporting system, including standards and assessment, curriculum and instruction, professional development and learning environment, which is lack in China’s frameworks. The study found that this disparity is closely related to the differences of cultural background, educational tradition, social environment, institutional arrangement, and educational evaluation systems of China and the United States; (2) These two frameworks reflected the debate between knowledge and skills: which should be the core of curriculum, knowledge or skills? The teaching of the 21st century competencies should be mono-disciplinary or interdisciplinary? Which is more effective for the development of the 21st century competencies, direct instruction or inquiry-based learning? To some extent, China teaches knowledge and America teaches how to think (Yong Zhao, 2014). The framework of mainland China has been criticized as ambiguity, which contains “all competencies”, not “key competencies” (Guo, 2016); emphasizes disciplinary knowledge, which is only developed by scholars and is not future-oriented (Peng, 2017). The American framework has been criticized for its over-emphasis on skills (Great Minds 2009, Hirsch 2009 2016, Ravitch 2009). The implementation of both frameworks has encountered obstacles in teaching and evaluating higher-order thinking skills. Since the college entrance examination is the Achilles’ heel of 21st century reforms in mainland China (Cheng, 2017), the obstacles to its implementation are even greater.

Finally, the implications of the implementation of 21st century competencies in educational practice are discussed and recommendations are provided. (1) For the cultivation of talents in China and the United States, higher-order thinking skills are very important. Global competition in the future is the competition of higher-order thinking skills that should be oriented to everyone and effective policy and practical arrangements should be developed for this. American schooling needs to strengthen knowledge delivering while focusing on the 21st century skills. For mainland China education, it needs to integrate 21st century competencies with its tradition of knowledge delivering. Both countries should adapt to their cultural traditions and learning habits. For China, it is necessary to learn from the experience of the 21st century skills education reform in the US and strengthen the cultivation of critical thinking and problem solving, cooperation and communication, creativity and innovation, and of ICT skills. (2) Inquiry-based learning should be emphasized for the effective cultivation of higher-order thinking skills, while direct instruction should not be ignored. Direct instruction is not necessarily ineffective, and student learning needs more capable “others.” Teacher’s strong intervention is important (John Hattie, 2009); (3) The cultivation of higher-order thinking skills requires more social space. Education should not be disconnected with the development of society and economy. Social innovation depends on a free social and institutional environment. The 21st century competencies are not the "the art of dragon slaughtering". It is difficult for an over-regulated society to enable students to develop and apply their competencies. Therefore, more social space is necessary for the cultivation, formation and application of capabilities in the 21st century.

Authors