Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Introduction
Emotional well-being strongly impacts an individual’s cognitive ability and academic achievement (Berson & Baggerly, 2016). Schools and classrooms have become a context for supporting student wellbeing, not just academically, but mentally, emotionally, and socially (Cefai & Cavioni, 2015). School climate is a salient part of individual achievement (Reynolds, Lee, Turner, & Bromhead, 2017), and of providing a contextual atmosphere for ongoing engagement and support (Fredricks, Blumenfeld, & Paris, 2016). While a number of schools have implemented Social Emotional learning (SEL) programs to best meet student needs (Coelho, 2017), the large majority of educators are attempting this feat outside the regular curriculum. Positive and supportive relationships among school leaders, teachers and students are crucial in creating a healthy classroom environment for students (Poulou, 2015; Jennings & DiPrete, 2010).
The purpose of this work is to explore the factors associated with social-emotional learning within the global classroom and school setting through both student and school leadership perspectives. It also seeks to provide a cross-sectional lens of student well-being among educational environments in the United States and Post-Socialist Eastern Europe, particularly Romania, Estonia, Lithuania, Slovak Republic, and Slovenia.
Specifically, this study aims to investigate the following areas: (1) the relationship between social emotional learning competencies and student success; (2) the degree to which school-level factors influence student attitudes, as represented through SEL indicators, and academic achievement; (3) cross-national differences among these relationships as they pertain to different demographics and country regimes.
Theoretical Framework
Indicators of individual well-being have revolved around development of various social and emotional skills (Ben-arieh, 2008; Miyamoto et al., 2015; Schonert-reichl et al., 2015). Social and emotional learning has been acknowledged as a process of integrating different components aimed at thinking, feeling, and behaving in a way that entails self-awareness, responsible decision making, and behavior management (Brackett & Rivers, 2012). Effectively combining cognitive, behavioral and emotional skills supports academic achievement by scaffolding ongoing social and educational development, particularly in school settings (McCormick, Connor, & McClowry, 2015; Brackett & Rivers, 2012). Developed by the Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning (CASEL), the Social – Emotional Learning (SEL) framework identifies five categories aimed at creating ideal conditions for lifelong individual success: self-awareness, self-management, social awareness, relationship management, and responsible decision making (CASEL, 2017).
In turn, each of these competencies have numerous factors to support systematic development of core social and emotional skills to help children thrive and overcome challenges in life (Smith & Low, 2013). Social and emotional competence is at the root of learning, as students cannot process new information if they are emotionally overwhelmed, or if their physical, psychological and emotional needs have not been met (Taylor & Larson, 1999; Smith & Low, 2013).
Schools and classrooms have become a context for supporting student well-being, not just academically, but mentally, emotionally, and socially (Cefai & Cavioni, 2015). Positive and supportive teacher-student relationships are crucial in creating a healthy classroom environment and facilitating social relationships among students (Jennings & DiPrete, 2010). The influence of these relationships also plays a particularly important role for students with behavioral and emotional difficulties (Poulou, 2015). School support is a salient foundation in individual achievement (Reynolds et al., 2017; Wang & Holcombe, 2010), but also in supporting growth through ongoing behavioral and emotional engagement (Fredricks et al., 2016). In school settings without official implementation of SEL programs, strong teachers are still delivering and scaffolding those necessary competencies, oftentimes without additional resources.
Depending on geographic, political, or historical perspectives, school climate and student beliefs vary greatly among countries. Extant research shows that integrated educational systems with higher standardization have higher educational equality and opportunities (Byun & Kim, 2010; Dupriez & Dumay, 2006); by contrast, countries with differentiated systems reproduce the existent educational inequality paradigm (Bodovski et al, 2017; Hallinan, 2016; Van de Werfhorst & Mijs, 2010). Furthermore, students in individualistic societies (Western Europe, United States) tend to exhibit higher confidence levels than those in collective ones (e.g. East Asian countries), despite achievement scores being higher in the latter (Chiu & Klassen, 2010; Lau, 2014). Students in more egalitarian countries tend to have higher rates of self-esteem and perception of their own abilities, increasing positive social and emotional well-being (Dupriez & Dumay, 2006; Morony et al, 2013).
Methods
This study utilizes the 2015 wave of PISA survey, focusing on student achievement in science within 72 participating countries. Dependent, independent and control variables were recoded for the multi-level statistical analysis. We employed factor loading analysis to create the multi-faceted measures of social emotional learning for five SEL indicators. School climate and related disciplinary factors served as additional predictors, while prior math achievement, parental education, and student background were controlled.
This proposed study utilizes a multilevel regression analysis, to allow for the nested structure of PISA data. This methodology accounts for dependency in the sample, as student characteristics within the same school might be similar or correlated with each other. This study employs a 2-level design: student data as level-1 variables, school characteristics and teacher responses as level-2 predictors (Bryk & Raudenbush, 1992). The analysis was run separately for five countries included in the study. Models were run as added regression analysis, pertaining to school climate, student background, previous achievement and associated confidence factors (Hallinan, 2016).
Preliminary Results
Initial findings suggest that social emotional indicators, and particularly supportive relationships among teachers and students, are predictors of higher emotional well-being as well as educational achievement. Results also suggest that a calm, positive school climate, along with previous educational achievement support motivation and a sense of belonging. Interestingly, gender differences favored females in Eastern Europe, with girls in developing nations showing higher self-efficacy and confidence than those in the United States.
Scholarly Significance
These findings provide a glimpse into a more comprehensive view of student well-being and social-emotional competence. The associations between individual self-beliefs and performance cannot be overlooked, particularly when globally sustainable educational programs clearly require more than just cognitive student support. The policy implications are also noteworthy, as school climate mechanisms play an integral role in continued educational success.