Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
This presentation will provide a comprehensive picture of the students’ performance in the Chinese societies from an international perspective using PISA data. The influence of various background factors such as family economic, social and cultural status (ESCS), social and academic segregation among schools, and immigrant status will also be explored with a focus on the latest results of the four Chinese societies participating in PISA 2015.
The findings show that firstly, the four Chinese societies continue to perform well and rank high among participating countries/economies in mathematics, science and reading and the pattern is consistent over the past six cycles of PISA. As for the equality in basic education, the Chinese societies have generally provided high quality and fairly high equity basic education as reflected by the low to modest impact of family economic, social and cultural status. In particular, the small impact that ESCS has on literacy performance in Hong Kong has further diminished in 2015, which suggests that Hong Kong students of all backgrounds appear to benefit from the education system fairly equally. Yet, the social segregation between schools as measured by mean ESCS still shows a strong and significant effect in Hong Kong as well as other Chinese societies in PISA.
Secondly, school academic segregation varies among the four Chinese societies. Results indicate that Chinese Taipei and Mainland China have a higher total variance and between–school heterogeneity than the OECD average in PISA 2015. These findings indicate that school segregation in these two Chinese societies is more serious than the OECD average as well as that in Macao and Hong Kong. The evidence shows that between-school variance of Hong Kong has decreased under the mild de-segregation policy by a gradual reduction in academic streaming from 5 into 3 bands. Yet, how teachers can manage student heterogeneity appears to be a challenge in Hong Kong and Macao.
Thirdly, Hong Kong and Macao have large proportions of immigrant students whereas Chinese Taipei and Mainland China are very homogenous. Findings indicate that Hong Kong shows a similar pattern as the OECD average in which native students perform better than the second-generation students, whereas the first-generation students are the worst in mathematics, science and reading. Yet, the second-generation students of Macao perform better than natives in all three literacy domains, a pattern which differs from that of the OECD countries.
Overall, the performance of the Chinese societies is outstanding and the Chinese societies have provided high quality and fairly high equity basic education. Yet, we share similar challenges of high academic and social segregation between schools. The disadvantage of immigrant students in some Chinese societies needs to be further examined in future studies. In addition to the equality within school, it is also worthy of investigating concern issues beyond school such as shadow education and pathways of students beyond basic education from the perspective of equality of opportunity.
摘 要:本匯報將採用PISA數據,從國際視野全面了解華人社會的學生表現,亦會以四個華人社會在PISA 2015的最新結果為重點,探討各種背景因素,例如家庭經濟、社會及文化地位(ESCS)、學校之間的社會及學能分隔、以及移民地位所帶來的影響。
結果發現,首先,四個華人社會在數學、科學及閱讀方面表現良好,在參與國家/地區中名列前茅,結果在過去六屆PISA一致。至於基礎教育均等方面,家庭經濟、社會及文化地位對學生表現的影響不大,反映華人社會普遍提供優質而相當均等的基礎教育。尤其在香港,家庭經濟、社會及文化地位對學生表現影響微小,在2015年更進一步減低,顯示不同背景的香港學生都能大致均等地從教育制度中獲益。然而,在香港以及其他華人社會,從家庭經濟、社會及文化地位的平均值可見,學校之間的社會經濟分隔仍對學生表現呈強而顯著的影響。
第二,四個華人社會的學校學能分隔各有不同。結果顯示,在PISA 2015,中華台北與中國大陸的學生表現總差異和校間差異,皆高於OECD平均值,反映這兩個地區的學校分隔比OECD國家、澳門和香港嚴重。證據亦顯示,在溫和的取消分隔政策之下,香港學校組別由五個減至三個,香港的校間差異隨之減少。然而,對香港和澳門教師而言,如何處理學生的個別差別實屬挑戰。
第三,香港和澳門有大比例的移民學生,但中華台北和中國大陸絕大部分為本地學生。結果顯示,香港的本地學生在數學、科學及閱讀方面的表現較第二代移民學生為佳,第一代移民學生表現則最差,結果與OECD平均值相似。然而,澳門的第二代移民學生在三個能力範疇上的表現均較本地學生出色,結果與OECD國家不同。
總括而言,華人社會的表現出色,亦提供優質而相當均等的基礎教育,但它們皆面對著高度的校間學能和社會分隔的挑戰。未來研究須進一步探討部份華人社會的移民學生身處的劣勢。除了基礎教育內均等外,學校以外的關注議題,例如影子教育和基礎教育後學生的出路,皆值得從機會均等的角度作出研究.