Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Tibetan culture has a complex and contested relationship with the idea of Indigenous communities across the world. I will argue that in relation to concepts and practices of place, and relationship to educational systems, there is tremendous utility in using Indigenous theories of knowledge and education to understand what has happened over the last 70 year of Chinese rule in Tibet. Tibetans are distinctive compared to many Indigenous communities for their 1200-year history of being highly literate, who produced hundreds of thousands of pages on diverse subjects, including accounts of place and knowledge production. I will engage with the following research questions in this paper: What constitutes Tibetan Land-centric ways of knowing and knowledge system?
Indigenous scholars have initiated a sea change of an academic past being researched by the settler academy to ushering in a new future of research by and with Indigenous people, as well as being rooted in Indigenous research paradigm or methodologies in recent decades (Smith, 1999; Wilson, 2008). In articulations of Indigenous research paradigm and methodologies, Indigenous scholars have foregrounded the centrality of Land or place in Indigenous knowledge systems and education for two main reasons (Wilson, 2008; Watts, 2013; Grande, 2005/2015; Tuck & McKenzie, 2015): First, Indigenous communities tend to have more rooted cosmological, cultural, spiritual, and genealogical connections with their homelands. Second, such foundations of their existence and life are threatened by settler colonialism and its land theft. The integrity of the Land, peoples, and their interrelations is thus a uniquely Indigenous political project (Grande & Anderson, 2017). By centering Indigenous ways of relating to Land/place in education, it enables us to treat Indigenous cosmologies and ontologies that are rooted in their cosmological, geological, and intellectual relationships with their homelands seriously in contemporary education and academic research. In Indigenous theories of knowledge and education, (i) Land (encompassing land, water, sky, air) is understood as a thinking, acting, and spiritual sovereign entity, knowledge and learning emerges from long-term interrelationships among people, places, and more-than human communities (Wilson, 2008;Watts, 2013;Whyte, 2017); (ii) responsible, reciprocal relationships (with Land, research participants, and ideas) that can be spiritual, embodied, experiential, and intellectual constitute methods of Indigenous knowledge (Wilson, 2008;Watts, 2013); and (iii) the purpose of Indigenous knowledge and education is to strengthen and build responsible, reciprocal, and resilient Indigenous relationships (including with Land or own’s cosmological world) (Wilson, 2008; Grande, 2015).
The substantive treatment of Land in Indigenous methodologies and the cosmological sense of being an inseparable part of a particular place physically and spiritually that is expressed in the concept of ‘Indigeneity’ (Whyte, 2016) make it meaningful for me to use Indigenous theories of knowledge and education in the context of considering Tibetan knowledge production and education. Similarly to how place is generally treated in the dominant Eurocentric education and research as merely a surface upon which human actions occur (Simpson, 2014), Tibetan studies and Tibetan education research in particular has rarely paid substantive attention to place, Tibetan place-based relationships, and ways of knowing. The studies of Tibetan pilgrimage, sacred sites, and territorial deities (Karmay, 1998; Huber,1999; Markley, 2013) have contributed greatly to the understanding of Tibetan concepts of place, personhood, and community in relation to place.These studies, however, seem to contribute little to methodologies that are grounded in Tibetan Land, ontologies, and cosmologies for research concerning Tibet and the Tibetan people overall. Recent research on Tibetan students’ ethnic/cultural identity construction in the context of schooling (Zenz, 2013; Yang, 2017) misses entirely Tibetan concepts of personhood and relationship with Land as a system of knowledge and education; instead it assumes that state schooling is the all-encompassing force of influence, source of knowledge, and points of conflict in which Tibetan students are immersed as they construct their identity or Tibetan-ness. This may reflect, in part, how Tibetan worldviews and ways of being in relation to places are silenced and marginalized in state formal education (Bass, 2008). Additionally, Chinese state schooling is also increasingly displacing Tibetan children’s opportunities to experience Tibetan systems of education including Tibetan Land by enforcing boarding school enrollment in Tibet and in distant Chinese cities (Yang, 2017).
However, Tibet and its more-than-human forces figure greatly in Tibetan ways of knowing as was attested in Terma revelations (Jacoby, 2014) and in recent publications of knowledge of mountains and rivers, ri chu’i rig gnas (Nyenpo Yutse, 2018). Tibetan creative literature, in particular, has seen a growing presence of Tibetan Land and lifeworld rooted in Tibetan Indigenous cosmologies and ontologies (e.g. short stories,“Snow” and “the Gathering of Gods and Spirits”). Given that the centrality of the Land (including more-than-human communities) in Tibetan ways of knowing has developed over many centuries and continues to undergird Tibetan life today, I argue that it is problematic not to take Tibetan ontologies and Land-centric ways of knowing seriously in Tibetan knowledge production and education. Hunt (2014) describes the absence or silencing of Indigenous ways of knowing in the contemporary dominant institutions and disciplines in North America as epistemic violence that establishes ontological limits of human intelligibility by “creating and sustaining boundaries around what is considered real and, by extension, what is unable to be seen as real (or to be seen at all)” (p.29).This paper, a chapter of my dissertation, attempts to articulate Tibetan Land-centric ways of knowing using Indigenous theories of knowledge and methodologies (Wilson, 2008; Watts, 2013; Tuck & McKenzie, 2015) as a theoretical framework to analyze Tibetan creation stories and other historical literature regarding concepts of place, knowledge, and community, in addition to secondary literature on Tibetan pilgrimage, sacred sites, territorial deity rituals. This research thus has a synergistic element which connects studies of Tibetan place and place-based rituals to Indigenous conceptualizations such as Land education (Tuck, McKenzie, McCoy, 2014; Styres, 2019) or Place-Thought (Watts, 2013) to envision a Tibetan Land-centric pedagogy and methodology. The history of Indigenous education and knowledge practices in Tibet and its articulation of the interrelationship between people and places could offer an important contribution to the growing community of Indigenous methodologies and scholarship.