Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Civil Society Organizations and Education Reform in the Global South: The Case of Brazil

Thu, April 21, 3:00 to 4:30pm CDT (3:00 to 4:30pm CDT), Hyatt Regency - Minneapolis, Floor: 2, Greenway B

Proposal

Existing accounts of philanthropic engagement in education have often focused on the dynamics of the global north, leading to a very limited understanding of how far this field extends (Ridge & Erfurth, 2021). Additionally, these narratives often adopt deficit-centered explanations of the increased engagement of civil society organizations with the education sector, reducing organizational change to market-driven needs. More recently, some scholars have started to highlight the cultural roots of changes in organizational engagement in education reform (Bromley et al., 2020; Bromley, 2020). However, these studies have often focused on cross-national trends, leaving several open questions about how political and cultural change at the local level might help to explain such changes.
Focusing on the specific case of Brazil, in this paper we use historical document analysis to explore how cultural and political changes over time have been associated with changes in organizational engagement with education. Looking at the stated missions and programmatic initiatives of civil society organizations over time, we shed some light on the ways in which the diffusion of ideologies focused on individual empowerment, along with scientized notions of knowledge production, helped to determine how these organizations ultimately engaged in reforming education. Then, we propose an understanding of civil society organizations as both shaping and being shaped by their cultural and historical context and suggest that further contextual changes (e.g., the fragmentation of the liberal order) foreshadow, once again, a change in how civil society organizations engage with education reform in the country.
Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) correspond to the population of citizens and formal entities, and covers its various forms of organization and expression, which can be legally constituted or spontaneous and informal (Oliveira, 2001; Haddad, 2001). They are linked to diverse and broad causes concerning all citizens, and refer to the participation of groups that act, from rights acquired through laws, in matters that were previously exclusive to the government (Fernandes, 1994; Oliveira, 2001; Haddad, 2001).
In Brazil, despite the fact that CSOs did not acquire legal standing until the 1990s, the history of philanthropic engagement with education goes back much further. We divide our account of CSO engagement with education reform in Brazil into four distinct periods: 1960-1985, 1985-2000, 2000-2014, and 2014-present.
The period between 1960 and 1985 is rather collectivistic in its orientation, with organizations either promoting charitable work for the common good or promoting social advocacy to proclaim democratic ideals. During the 1960s and 1970s, organizations were created in churches, political parties and universities in order to work on behalf of the poorest population. The Catholic church, based on the Liberation Theology and Marxist precepts, carried out the work of popular education (Fernandes, 1994). Until the mid-1980s, popular social movements were driven by a common goal that would override any individualized interest of a particular group: the achievement of democracy.
In the post-dictatorship period, starting in 1985, the form of political participation and representation changed. A process of individualization of the aspirations of each social group triggered the multiplication of organizations in civil society (Thisiena, 2009). Consequently, CSOs expand dramatically, this time focusing on re-democratizing access to education-partly in response to an overarching ideology that increasingly focuses on the inherent dignity of the individual. In some cities in Brazil, the number of CSOs almost tripled from the 1970s to the 1980s (Avritzer, 2012). This period culminates in 1999, with the enactment of law 9,790, which bestowed upon non-profit private legal entities the title of Civil Society Organizations of Public Interest (BRASIL, 1999).
The period starting in the 2000s is marked by an increased engagement between CSOs, the private sector and the government. Rather than working alongside the government through public-private partnerships, these organizations start to adopt a logic of “muscular philanthropy” (Smith, 2004). Rather than running their own programs, CSO start working through the government in order to enact systemic change. This period culminates with law n.13109, in 2014, which established the legal framework for partnerships between the public administration and civil society organizations (BRASIL, 2014). This and other governmental decrees effectively created a space for the state to transfer the execution of public policies to civil society.
In the post-2014 period, the boundaries between CSOs and the government become completely blurred. With the construction of the National Common Curriculum and with the “New High School”, it is possible to perceive the intimate relationship between the public and private sectors. These two documents, which are landmarks of the Brazilian educational reform, had as active actors the CSOs, which were responsible for preparing the document and implementing it.
Our findings provide several contributions to existing research in the field of Philanthropy in Education. First, we suggest that, indeed, changes in organizational actorhood connect to overarching cultural changes at the local and global levels, beyond market-driven needs. However, we find that CSOs are also part and parcel of the process of constructing such cultural context. In that sense, we find supporting evidence for cultural accounts of organizational change which portray civil society organizations as social actors rather than merely passive entities.
Secondly, we suggest that education reform narratives that are single-mindedly focused on state-centered education policies might be missing a good deal of what might actually be happening in the background, with CSOs acquiring an increasingly central role. Moreover, since the boundaries have been blurred, it is no longer possible to talk about civil society organizations as simply operating parallel to or in contrast with government agencies.

Authors