Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to present and discuss the QITABI 2 Early Warning System (EWS) used for supporting struggling readers. The system, typically implemented over a full academic year, was adapted for the summer catch up program Core features of the EWS adapted model include rapid teacher-led diagnostic reading assessment, simple analysis of students’ results based on four readers’ categories, and immediate planning for reading support.
The USAID funded Quality Instruction Towards Access and Basic Education Improvement 2 (QITABI 2) project aims to improve student language learning — Arabic, English, and French —, Math skills, and SEL in schools across Lebanon, grades 1 – 6. The project implements its activities in close collaboration with the Ministry of Education and Higher Education (MEHE), the Department D’observation Pedgogique Scolaire (DOPS) teacher mentors, and the Center of Educational Research and Development (CRDP).
Context
During the two academic years, 2019-2021, schools in Lebanon underwent repetitive closures due to COVID 19 and other challenging factors such as street protests, dire economic conditions, and lack of governmental leadership. Poor access to online learning deprived many primary grade students, particularly those from low socio-economic backgrounds.
The end-of-year school test results showed that many students did not acquire grade-level skills. A learning recovery study conducted by QITABI 2 in 120 public schools showed that grades 2 and 3 students were overwhelmingly reading at the beginner level, which is well below their expected grade levels. Even before COVID 19 pandemic, many struggling readers, in the absence of diagnostic assessment and adequate in-class support,were exposed to classroom retention, reaching 10% in grade 4 and even to school drop-out, reaching 3% in the first primary cycle (CERD 2008).
Rapid Teacher-Led Diagnostic Assessment
In response to the ministry’s need to support teachers with a reading program tailored for the summer catch up program, QITABI 2 adapted the EWS reading diagnostic assessment teacher tools. The EWS diagnostic reading tools are designed for cycle 1 (grades 1-3) and cycle 2 (grades 4-6) students to help teachers rapidly identify students’ reading levels . In cycle 1, teachers relied on simple tools to test the students’ basic reading skills: Alphabet knowledge, phonics, sight words, fluency, and reading comprehension. In cycle 2, tests focused on assessing reading comprehension. Teachers conducted the assessment in groups using two reading-level texts. The ‘first text’ assesses semester one reading comprehension skills, while the ‘second text’ assesses semester 2 reading comprehension skills. Students’ results were analyzed using a rating scale to place students in one of the 4-reading categories: Emergent, Intermediate, Advanced, and Accelerated. From the total number of the 677 teachers observed during the summer catch up program, 59% used the diagnostic assessment.
Supportive literacy material and educational games were also provided to teachers to carry on evidence-based in-class support for 20 minutes per day for five weeks.
Every Arabic, English, and French session started with a circle time or meeting time, encouraging students to engage in socio-emotional activities to express themselves and socialize with their peers. Next teacher read aloud a story and encouraged students to discuss, express their feelings, reflect, and comment. After presenting the lesson planned at grade level, the teacher facilitated independent work for the advanced and accelerated students and worked closely for 20 minutes with the Emergent and Intermediate groups and of students. The session ended with a reflection about learning as readers.
The intervention for Emergent Reader focused on phonemic awareness, phonics, sight words, fluency, and reading comprehension from decodable texts extracted from QITABI 2 Emergent readers e-kits. Sustainable Literacy resources provided under QITABI (2015- 2019) and QITABI 2 grades 1-6 e-lessons were also used to support Intermediate readers.
Challenges and Lessons learned
One of the main challenges is getting teachers to understand the value of diagnostic assessment and prioritize it as a practice for planning differentiated instruction. Teachers also seemed far from realizing that reading is a key learning skill. Still, during the summer catch-up program, many teachers expressed their opinion in prioritizing teaching grammar and spelling over emphasizing reading.
Teachers need to learn the underpinning theories of reading and reading assessment, drawing on students’ developmental continuum of reading skills. Some teachers seemed only aware of the skills they teach in their classrooms and have little knowledge of how students’ reading skills progress and evolve.
Further lessons learned and insights of the EWS implementation at the summer catch-up program will be shared after reflection sessions with the ministry’s coaches, QITABI 2 field team of learning facilitators, and the M&E team.
Quality Instruction Towards Access and Basic Education Improvement 2 (QITABI 2) is a USAID-funded project which seeks to improve student learning of all languages (Arabic, English French), math, and SEL in the early grades (grades 1 – 6) in close collaboration with Ministry of Education and Higher Education (MEHE), the Department D’observation pedgogique Scolaire (DOPS) teacher mentors, and the Center of Educational Research and Development (CERD).