Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
This paper examines how policy actors in Norway and Sweden utilize references in their official education policy documents. In an era of evidence-based policymaking, policy actors are expected to support their claims and proposals with credible sources. References in policy documents have been used to investigate how policy actors evidentiate their assertions and position themselves in the larger discursive policy space (Ozga, 2019; Steiner-Khamsi, 2021). An examination of references therefore allows us to understand whose and what types of knowledge are utilized to reduce uncertainty or obtain legitimacy in the education policy process.
Scholars in comparative and international education have long examined references in education policymaking. In particular, a great number of studies on references have explored how and why particular countries or international organizations are referenced in various national contexts, incorporating the theoretical constructs of “externalization” and “reference societies” (e.g., Santos & Kauko, 2020; Takayama & Apple 2008; Waldow 2017). They have found that policy actors make references to the external systems to problematize the current education landscape, to advance their own political agenda, or to legitimize policy change. In addition, the infrastructural and epistemological influence of international organizations such as OECD on global governance in education has been highlighted (Sellar & Lingard, 2013). However, previous work on references in policymaking has mostly focused on “external” references. In order to fully comprehend the role of references as evidence in policymaking, this study extends the investigation to include non-external references in policy documents.
This study is part of an international research project on the use and production of policy knowledge and evidence in five Nordic countries: Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, and Sweden. Using bibliometric network analysis, our earlier work has examined the architecture of policy knowledge, which includes the links between policy documents and different knowledge sources. By analyzing policy documents prepared for the most recent education reform in each country and their references, we could identify particular actors, organizations, and bodies of knowledge that were central in the policy knowledge networks and explore their variation by policy-level and national contexts. Building on previous work, this study pays closer attention to the nature of the links between policy documents and other knowledge sources. The policy documents may reference a knowledge source, but the purpose of referencing could be positive (e.g., to agree, to support), negative (e.g., to disagree, to criticize), or even neutral (e.g., to describe). Furthermore, the practice of referencing should be understood in the specific context in which the policy documents are situated. Thus, this study asks the following questions: In what ways are the references actually utilized? How is the practice of referencing similar or different across reform periods and national contexts?
To address the questions, this study closely looks into white papers prepared for curriculum reforms in Norway and Sweden over two reform periods. It focuses on Norway and Sweden because the evidence-based policy planning practice is highly institutionalized in these two countries. The total sample includes two Norwegian white papers, “St.meld. nr. 30 (2003-2004): Kultur for læring” prepared for the 2006 Knowledge Promotion reform (LK06) and “St.meld.nr. 28 (2015–2016): Fag - Fordypning - Forståelse - En fornyelse av Kunnskapsløftet” prepared for the 2016/2020 Subject Renewal (LK20), and two Swedish white papers, “Regeringens proposition 2008/09:87 Tydligare mål och kunskapskrav – nya läroplaner för skolan” prepared for the 2011 curriculum reform and “Regeringens proposition 2017/18:182 Samling för skolan” prepared for the 2015/2018 curriculum reform. Each document is coded and analyzed regarding its reference utilization using NVivo.
The preliminary results show the differences between Norwegian and Swedish white papers in terms of how the references are utilized. For example, on one hand, the references in the Swedish white papers were mainly limited to government-published documents (laws, bills, parliamentary motions, government regulations, etc.). They were commonly used to establish an institutional legacy, regarding how the government had worked to address a policy problem. On the other hand, the references in the Norwegian white papers were more open to scientific sources (books, journal articles), and they were often used to diagnose a policy problem or to support the proposed changes. In both countries, the main nature of referencing did not change much over the reform periods; however, more explicit presentation and utilization of references were evident in the most recent reforms. In the full presentation, I will report the final results and discuss them considering (1) the expected function of white paper and (2) cultural-historical contexts on evidence-based policymaking in Norway and Sweden.