Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Over the past decade, there has been an increase in the saliency of white ethnonationalism in western democracies. Ethnonationalism has not only infiltrated the political discourse but in some cases begun to infiltrate legislation and policy. To combat and offer an alternative to ethnonationalist policies we first need to understand the phenomenon (McKinney, 2018). This study further develops an understanding of white ethnonationalism and how it is pervading education policy by conducting a critical discourse analysis of government policy documents addressing education in the United States and Hungary.
In Hungary, I examine recent amendments made to the Fundamental Law of Hungary that address education as well as recent updates to the National Core Curriculum. In the United States, I examine the Trump Administration’s 1776 Commission Report as well as Florida’s The Stop Woke Act. Using these documents, I conduct a critical discourse analysis using the Wodak (2015) discourse historical approach. In examining these documents, we can identify the challenges that white ethnonationalism poses to western education systems and we can begin to think about how to counteract those policies.
In this study, I build upon a growing body of literature on the comparison of ethnonationalism in public education across the globe. Agbaria (2018) constructed a comparison between Israeli education and the Apartheid in South Africa. The study specifically looked at curricular developments that are influenced by the radical right and the attempt to promote Jewish identity. Hyman (2020) also makes a comparison with Apartheid South Africa but connects it to modern American white supremacy. Rather than compare against historical regimes, this study compares two current western democracies and how white ethnonationalism manifests in specific government policies addressing education.
While the United States and Hungary are both democracies, they each have a unique political and historical context that makes for an intriguing comparison. The United States is a large, diverse society with a well-established democracy. However, historically the conception of what is “American” has been white, English-speaking, and protestant Christian (Solomon et al, 2021). Hungary is an older and significantly smaller nation that has been a crossroads for many different ethnic groups throughout history. Hungary was a satellite republic of the Soviet Union and only recently became a western-style democracy. While they have different political histories, there has been a recent move by conservatives across the globe to look at Hungary as a political model due to its emphasis on Christian democracy (Neumann, 2022). This sharing of ideas by conservatives across the globe is what makes this comparison intriguing.
If scholars in the field of Comparative and International Education want to truly address the issue of equity in education, we first need to examine the obstacles to equity. White ethnonationalism is an emerging threat to equity in education. This work builds on our understanding of white ethnonationalism in education to combat the threat it poses.