Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

What do Japanese teachers say about the teaching standards?

Sun, February 19, 4:45 to 6:15pm EST (4:45 to 6:15pm EST), Grand Hyatt Washington, Floor: Constitution Level (3B), Constitution E

Proposal

1. Introduction
There have been standard-based education reforms developed around the world since the 1980s to set student learning goals, and specify the required teaching standards. Generally, there have been two perspectives on teaching standards: 1) a regulatory approach, and 2) a development approach (Sachs, 2005). Teaching standards based on a regulatory approach have been criticized for inhibiting teacher autonomy and creativity. (Miller ed., 1995). However, standards that take a development approach tend to be more valued as they provide professional development opportunities for teachers.
As new teaching standards have been introduced in the last few years in Japan, few studies have been conducted on the efficacy of these standards, and very few have focused on the teachers’ perceptions of these standards (Auchi, ed., 2020). Therefore, this study aimed to determine the answers to the following questions.
1) To what extent do Japanese teachers find the teaching standards valuable?; and,
2) If they find them valuable, what are the teachers’ expectations for fulfilling these requirements?

2. Theoretical framework: stance toward the teaching standards
Many people ask whether these standards are being introduced to control teachers or to develop their teaching. The characteristics of the “regulatory approach” to teaching standards are: 1) a focus on accountability; 2) a technical approach to teaching and monitoring teaching performances; and 3) an external imposition of the standards by a government instrumentality. The characteristics of the “developmental approach” are: 1) a student-centered approach to both teaching and learning; 2) a systematic monitoring process to ensure accountability; and 3) an idea that teachers should be lifelong learners (Sachs, 2010). Sachs proposed three standards policy expectations: 1) improve teaching performances; 2) improve teachers’ standing; and 3) contribute to ongoing professional teacher development (Sachs, 2010).

3. Methodology
This study conducted a qualitative study on Japanese teachers’ perceptions of the teaching standards. The ten study participants were all graduate students and in-service teachers, each of whom had around ten years of practical experience and had decided to attend graduate school for professional development. After introducing the teaching standard concept in the post-graduate classes, focus group interviews were conducted in a safe setting, which were primarily focused on how the teachers viewed and applied the teaching standards to their practice. All interview data were recorded with consent and transcribed, with the consequent data analysis process following an inductive process.

4. Findings & Conclusion
The study found the following results. 1) The teachers’ perceptions were diverse; some expressed a hope that the standards could serve as a “common language” for their reflections, whereas others saw the standards as controlling. 2) While most expected the teaching standards to improve their teaching, they did not expect them to improve the teachers' standing or contribute to their ongoing professional learning.
These findings indicated that to ensure teachers’ voices as part of the policy-making process, it is important that teachers be given the opportunity to discuss the aims and rationale of these teaching standards and associated policies, which would enhance the overall effectiveness.

Authors